At a glance
| Item | Position |
|---|---|
| Act and provision | Income-tax Act, 2025, section 375 |
| Official heading | Procedure when assessee claims identical question of law is pending before High Court or Supreme Court. |
| Location | Chapter XVIII: Appeals, revisions and alternate dispute resolutions; Part B: Special provisions for avoiding repetitive appeals |
| General commencement | 1 April 2026 |
| Research date | 15 October 2026 |
| Legal status | Enacted and operative |
| Legal function | Assessee declaration to avoid a repetitive legal appeal |
The section operates within the Act’s charging and computation framework. The period and applicable version must be identified before applying it. S1, sections 1(3), 3, 4 and 375
Both cases belong to the same assessee
The relevant case is pending before the AO or an appellate authority for one tax year; the other case is the same assessee’s case for another tax year. The legal questions must be identical. Similar commercial facts, a common adviser or a case of another taxpayer is not enough for this subsection. S1, Section 375(1)(a)
The other question must be pending in a listed higher proceeding
The listed routes include old-Act High Court reference under section 256 or appeal under section 260A; Supreme Court reference under section 257 or appeal under section 261; new section 365 High Court or section 367 Supreme Court appeal; or an Article 136 SLP against a Tribunal or jurisdictional High Court order. Preserve the specific proceeding and pending-question requirements. S1, Section 375(1)(b)(i), Section 375(1)(b)(ii), Section 375(1)(b)(iii), Section 375(1)(b)(iv), Section 375(1)(b)(v)
The declaration gives a specific undertaking
The assessee declares that, if the AO or appellate authority agrees to apply the other case’s final legal decision, the assessee will not raise that question in the relevant case before an appellate authority or later higher forum. This is a choice with a legal consequence, not merely a request to postpone payment or hold every issue indefinitely. S1, Section 375(1), concluding words
The AO participates when the declaration is made in appeal
The appellate authority calls for the AO’s report on correctness of the claim and gives the AO a hearing opportunity if requested. The assessee’s assertion of identity is therefore subject to examination, not automatically accepted. S1, Section 375(2)(a), Section 375(2)(b)
A written identity decision is required
The AO or appellate authority may admit the claim if satisfied that the questions are identical, or reject it otherwise. That subsection (3) order is final and cannot be challenged by appeal or revision under this Act. The wording concerns those statutory challenges; it does not purport to decide every constitutional remedy. S1, Section 375(3)(a), Section 375(3)(b), Section 375(4)
Admission does not require the relevant case to wait
After admission, the relevant case may be disposed of before the other case’s final legal decision. The assessee cannot separately raise that same question through the described appellate chain for the relevant case. Other issues are not waived merely because this particular question is covered. S1, Section 375(5)(a), Section 375(5)(b)
The final answer must later be applied
Once the other case’s legal decision becomes final, it is applied to the relevant case and the earlier disposal order amended if necessary. The mechanism follows the final answer, not only an answer favourable to the assessee. S1, Section 375(6)
Defined terms set the boundaries
Appellate authority means Joint Commissioner (Appeals), Commissioner (Appeals) or ITAT. Case includes total-income assessment or penalty/fine proceedings. Subsequent higher appeal means the specified High Court/Supreme Court appeal or Article 136 SLP against the Tribunal or jurisdictional High Court order. S1, Section 375(7)(a), Section 375(7)(b), Section 375(7)(c)
Form 117 and verification
Rule 194 prescribes Form 117, verified as indicated and signed by the Rule 167(3) return-authorised person. Submission to either first-appellate authority is in duplicate; submission to ITAT is in triplicate. These are the notified requirements; do not replace them with an assumed old form number. S2, rules 194 and 167(3)
Hypothetical illustrations
Identity accepted, other case still pending
Facts: For tax year 2026–27, the same assessee’s legal question for another year is pending in a listed higher forum, and its Form 117 identity claim is admitted for the current case.
Assumptions: The stated facts are hypothetical and supported by records. Any rates illustrated are base income-tax rates; surcharge, cess, interest and penalties are excluded unless expressly calculated.
Question: Must the AO wait before disposing of the current case?
Analysis: No. Subsection (5)(a) permits disposal now. When the other decision becomes final it must be applied, with amendment if needed; the assessee cannot independently re-appeal that covered question meanwhile.
Conclusion: The mechanism avoids repetition rather than mandating an indefinite pause. S1, S2
Reader questions
Can this section use another taxpayer’s case as the other case?
Subsection (1)(a) uses the same assessee’s other tax year. Section 376 is a separate departmental mechanism with a broader other-case description. S1