ITA 2025Converter

Income-tax Act 2025 Section 365 · Deep dive

Section 365 of the Income-tax Act, 2025: Appeal to High Court

Admission, precise questions, condonation, hearing limits, judgment and certified-copy implementation. S1, section 365

By the ITA Editorial TeamLaw checked as of 15 October 2026 4 min read

Prepared with AI-assisted research from the official sources listed at the end of this article.

Quick answer

Section 365 permits an appeal from an ITAT appellate order where the High Court is satisfied that a substantial question of law arises, ordinarily within 120 days of receipt. S1, section 365

At a glance

ItemPosition
Act and provisionIncome-tax Act, 2025, section 365
Official headingAppeal to High Court.
LocationChapter XVIII: Appeals, revisions and alternate dispute resolutions; Part A: Appeals; 3: Appeals to High Court
General commencement1 April 2026
Research date15 October 2026
Legal statusEnacted and operative
Legal functionHigh Court appeals on substantial questions of law

The section operates within the Act’s charging and computation framework. The period and applicable version must be identified before applying it. S1, sections 1(3), 3, 4 and 365

A substantial question of law is the gateway

An appeal lies from an order passed in appeal by the Tribunal when the High Court is satisfied that the case involves a substantial question of law. Disagreement with the Tribunal’s result is not itself this statutory test. The article does not classify a particular disputed factual finding as substantial without analysing the record and binding law. S1, Section 365(1)

Identify the appellant and receipt date

The Principal Chief Commissioner, Chief Commissioner, Principal Commissioner, Commissioner or an aggrieved assessee may file. The ordinary period is 120 days from receipt of the appealed order by the relevant assessee or named authority. Keep the order and reliable receipt evidence, including the applicable section 363(10) communication record. S1, Section 365(2), opening words, Section 365(2)(a)

The memorandum must precisely state the question

The appeal memorandum must state the substantial question of law precisely. A general request to reconsider everything does not supply the required formulation. Separate proposed legal questions from the factual background supporting them. S1, Section 365(2)(b)

Sufficient cause can justify late admission

The High Court may admit an appeal beyond 120 days when satisfied of sufficient cause for not filing within that period. A reasoned condonation request and evidence of the delay are necessary practical steps; admission is not automatic merely because the power exists. S1, Section 365(3)

The Court formulates the admitted question

Where satisfied, the Court formulates the substantial question. The appeal is heard on that question, and respondents may argue that the case does not involve it. Admission does not deprive the respondent of that express contention. S1, Section 365(4), Section 365(5)

Another substantial question can be heard for recorded reasons

The Court may hear another substantial question not previously formulated if satisfied that the case involves it and reasons are recorded. This is a controlled extension under subsection (6), not an unrestricted rehearing of all facts. S1, Section 365(6)

The judgment addresses law, reasons and possible costs

The Court decides the formulated legal question and gives a judgment containing its grounds. It may award costs as it thinks fit. A cost award is not automatically identical to the disputed tax or the expenses a party incurred. S1, Section 365(7)

Unresolved or wrongly determined issues can also be addressed

The Court may determine an issue the Tribunal did not determine, or an issue wrongly determined by reason of its decision on the substantial question of law. Preserve the stated connection to the legal-question jurisdiction; do not describe this as a general fresh assessment. S1, Section 365(8)(a), Section 365(8)(b)

Civil procedure applies subject to the Act

Unless this Act otherwise provides, CPC provisions concerning High Court appeals apply as far as may be. The section does not itself supply every registry requirement, court fee or electronic-filing direction; those need the relevant court’s applicable rules. S1, Section 365(9)

The AO gives effect using a certified judgment copy

When the High Court delivers its appellate judgment, the AO gives effect on the basis of a certified copy. Distinguish obtaining the judgment, communicating the certified copy and implementing the tax consequence. Section 369 separately states that filing a higher appeal does not itself stop tax being payable. S1, Section 365(10)

Choose the governing Act before choosing the appeal route

This article explains the 2025 Act. Section 536 preserves the earlier Act for the specified earlier-year proceedings; the date of an appellate order alone does not decide which Act governs. Keep the assessment period, initiating proceeding, order appealed against and its communication record together. The section numbers and new prescribed forms here should not be copied automatically into a saved 1961-Act proceeding. S1, section 536(2)(c)

Hypothetical illustrations

A proposed legal question versus mere dissatisfaction

Facts: For tax year 2026–27, an appellant’s draft says only that the Tribunal’s conclusion is unfair and asks for every factual issue to be heard again.

Assumptions: The stated facts are hypothetical and supported by records. Any rates illustrated are base income-tax rates; surcharge, cess, interest and penalties are excluded unless expressly calculated.

Question: Does this alone establish the section 365 gateway?

Analysis: No. The memorandum must precisely state a substantial question of law and the High Court must be satisfied it arises. Whether a particular alleged error meets that standard depends on the record and law; the example does not determine a real appeal’s merits.

Conclusion: Identify and support the legal question before filing. S1

Reader questions

Can a High Court appeal be admitted after 120 days?

Yes, if the Court is satisfied that sufficient cause prevented timely filing. The power does not guarantee condonation. S1

Sources

  1. S1Income-tax Act, 2025, as amended by Finance Act, 2026 — Income Tax Department, Ministry of Finance, Government of India (accessed 15 October 2026)

Related deep dives

← All Income-tax Act 2025 section deep dives