At a glance
| Item | Position |
|---|---|
| Act and provision | Income-tax Act, 2025, section 366 |
| Official heading | Case before High Court to be heard by not less than two Judges. |
| Location | Chapter XVIII: Appeals, revisions and alternate dispute resolutions; Part A: Appeals; 3: Appeals to High Court |
| General commencement | 1 April 2026 |
| Research date | 15 October 2026 |
| Legal status | Enacted and operative |
| Legal function | High Court bench and split-opinion procedure |
The section operates within the Act’s charging and computation framework. The period and applicable version must be identified before applying it. S1, sections 1(3), 3, 4 and 366
A section 365 appeal requires at least two judges
An appeal filed under section 365 is heard by a bench of not fewer than two High Court judges. It is decided according to their opinion or the majority opinion where there is a majority. The provision concerns this statutory appellate route; it is not a rule about the bench composition of every kind of High Court proceeding. S1, Section 366(1)
An equal division produces a reference of the legal point
If there is no majority, the judges state the point of law on which they differ. One or more other High Court judges then hear that point only. The final outcome on it follows the majority of all judges who heard the case, including the original judges. This is not an automatic transfer of the entire appeal for an unrestricted fresh hearing. S1, Section 366(2)
Bench composition does not remove the appeal gateway
Section 365 still requires a substantial question of law and governs limitation, the memorandum, formulation and the judgment. Section 366 supplies bench and voting procedure once that route is invoked; it does not create a second independent right to appeal or enlarge the subject of the reference. S1, sections 365–366
Hypothetical illustrations
A third judge resolves a split point
Facts: For tax year 2026–27, two judges hearing a section 365 appeal differ on a stated point of law. A third judge hears that point and agrees with the first judge.
Assumptions: The stated facts are hypothetical and supported by records. Any rates illustrated are base income-tax rates; surcharge, cess, interest and penalties are excluded unless expressly calculated.
Question: Whose opinions determine the point?
Analysis: The first and third judges form a two-to-one majority when all three relevant opinions are counted. The original second judge’s opinion is included but is the minority. Other matters are not automatically reopened merely because this point was referred.
Conclusion: Count the original judges as well as the additional judge. S1
Reader questions
Can this section alone justify a single-judge hearing of a section 365 appeal?
No. Subsection (1) requires a bench of at least two judges. The additional-judge mechanism in subsection (2) follows a stated difference; it does not replace that initial requirement. S1