At a glance
| Item | Position |
|---|---|
| Act and provision | Income-tax Act, 2025, section 99 |
| Official heading | Income of individual to include income of spouse, minor child, etc. |
| Location | Chapter V: Income of other persons included in total income of assessee |
| Legal status | Enacted and operative; editorial draft |
| General commencement | 1 April 2026 |
| Legal function | Family-income attribution and converted HUF property |
What clubbing changes, and what it does not
Clubbing is the usual explanatory term for including one person’s specified income in another individual’s total income. Section 99 states the legal triggers; it does not tax every receipt earned by every family member in the highest earner’s hands. Identify the relevant clause, the income’s source, the relationship and the applicable exceptions. S1, section 99(1)
A gift can be excluded from the recipient’s gift-income computation under section 92(3)(a), while later interest, rent or other income from the gifted asset is attributed under section 99. These rules address different events. The section also does not itself transfer civil ownership of an asset merely because its income is included elsewhere. S1, sections 92(3)(a), 99(1)(a)(ii) and 99(3)
Section 99(1)(a)(i): spouse remuneration from a concern
Salary, commission, fees and other remuneration, in cash or kind, received by a spouse from a concern in which the individual has a substantial interest fall within clause (a)(i). The exception concerns income solely attributable to application of the spouse’s technical or professional knowledge, experience and technical or professional qualification. A degree or family relationship alone does not resolve that test: the actual work and reason for the remuneration matter. S1, section 99(1)(a)(i)
Section 99(5)(a)(iii) defines substantial interest for this clause. For a company, the individual alone or jointly with relatives must beneficially own qualifying shares carrying at least 20% voting power at any time during the tax year. Fixed-rate-dividend shares of the described kind are excluded. For another concern, the individual alone or with relatives must be entitled to at least 20% of profits at any time during the year. This is neither an end-of-year-only test nor a universal 20%-of-capital test. S1, section 99(5)(a)(iii)(A)–(B)
For these relatives, read the Act’s general definition in section 2(94): spouse, brother, sister and the individual’s maternal or paternal lineal ascendants or descendants. Do not silently import the wider gift-relative list in section 92(5)(g), which serves that section’s specific purpose. S1, sections 2(94), 92(5)(g) and 99(5)(a)(iii)
Which spouse includes the remuneration?
For clause (1)(a)(i), section 99(5)(a)(i) chooses the spouse whose total income before that inclusion is greater. Once the income is included in one spouse’s total income for a tax year, subsection (5)(a)(ii) prevents an automatic switch to the other in a succeeding year unless the Assessing Officer is satisfied after giving the other spouse an opportunity of hearing. S1, section 99(5)(a)(i)–(ii)
This greater-income rule belongs to the remuneration clause. Do not apply it to every gifted-asset case: clause (1)(a)(ii) identifies the individual who transferred the asset. Nor does the text give a free annual choice of spouse. If pre-inclusion incomes are equal, the quoted greater-income test supplies no explicit tie-break in this section; a real tied case requires specific review rather than inventing one. S1, section 99(1)(a)(ii) and (5)(a)
Section 99(1)(a)(ii): assets transferred to a spouse
Income arising directly or indirectly from assets transferred directly or indirectly to the spouse otherwise than for adequate consideration is included, except a transfer in connection with an agreement to live apart. The clause is subject to section 25(a), which treats the transferor as owner for specified house-property transfers. Check that rule before treating all spouse-held rent as an ordinary section 99 interest-style calculation. S1, sections 99(1)(a)(ii) and 25(a)
Adequate consideration is not established merely because the deed mentions a token price. Likewise, an ordinary family understanding is not automatically an agreement to live apart. Trace the actual transfer and the causal connection to the income. Assets acquired entirely from the spouse’s independent resources are not swept into this clause merely because the spouses are married. S1, section 99(1)(a)(ii)
Section 99(1)(b) and (d): son’s wife and indirect benefit arrangements
Clause (b) concerns income from assets transferred directly or indirectly to the individual’s son’s wife without adequate consideration on or after 1 June 1973. The date qualifies this transfer rule. It is not a rule attributing every daughter-in-law’s independent earnings to a parent-in-law. S1, section 99(1)(b)
Clause (d) addresses assets transferred without adequate consideration to another person or an association of persons, to the extent their income provides an immediate or deferred benefit for the individual’s spouse or son’s wife. The son’s-wife limb excludes assets transferred before 1 June 1973. Routing the benefit through an intermediary or deferring its enjoyment does not by itself avoid the clause. Only the income to the specified extent is included; the section does not assume all of an intermediary’s income has that purpose. S1, section 99(1)(d)
Section 99(1)(c): minor-child income and three exclusions
Minor-child income is included subject to three exclusions: income on account of work done by the child; income from activities applying the child’s skill, talent, specialised knowledge or experience; and income where the minor has a disability of the nature specified in section 154. The first two are source-based exceptions. The disability wording concerns the qualifying child, and the referenced disability definitions must be checked through sections 154 and 127. S1, section 99(1)(c)(i)–(iii), sections 154(3) and 127
Unlike the spouse gifted-asset rule, this clause is not limited to assets gifted by a parent. Interest on property a minor inherited from someone else can still require clubbing. Equally, the exception for a child’s performance fees does not automatically exempt every later investment return from saving those fees: the later income’s own source must be tested. S1, section 99(1)(c)
Section 99(5)(b): parent selection and the limited minor-income exclusion
If the parents’ marriage subsists, the minor’s includible income goes to the parent with greater total income before inclusion. If their marriage does not subsist, it goes to the parent who maintains the child during the tax year. Once included with one parent, the income is not shifted in a succeeding year unless the Assessing Officer is satisfied after giving the other parent an opportunity of hearing. Custody or the receiving bank account alone is not a substitute for these rules. S1, section 99(5)(b)(i)–(ii) and concluding words
Schedule III, Table item 17 excludes up to ₹1,500 of the includible income for each minor child. This is a separate exclusion, not an exception written into section 99. Section 202(2)(a)(i) disallows that Schedule III item when computing income under section 202(1). Accordingly the ₹1,500 benefit is not available in that regime. A family should not assume the same clubbed-income amount in both regimes. S1, Schedule III, Table item 17; section 202(2)(a)(i)
Section 99(2): transferred assets put into a business or firm
Where the spouse or son’s wife invests the covered transferred assets in a business, or contributes them as capital to a firm as partner or for admission to partnership benefits, subsection (2) uses A = B × (C ÷ D). A is the income included with the transferor. B is the income and interest, or both, arising to the spouse or son’s wife from that business or firm during the tax year. C is the value of the transferred assets invested or contributed on the first day of the tax year. D is the total investment or capital contribution on that day. S1, section 99(2)
Opening-day amounts matter. Do not replace them with closing capital or a convenient annual average. A capital introduction after the first day, a zero denominator or a mixed-source reorganisation needs careful statutory analysis rather than an invented pro-rata shortcut. Also determine what income is chargeable before applying a clubbing computation; this formula does not by itself remove a separate exclusion for a qualifying firm profit share. S1, section 99(2) and Schedule III, Table item 2
Finance Act, 2026 corrected the spouse reference in subsection (2) to (1)(a)(ii), the asset-transfer rule. The superseded reference to spouse remuneration in (1)(a)(i) must not be used for the current formula. The son’s-wife reference remains clause (b). S4, sections 1(2)(a) and 45; S1, section 99(2)
Section 99(3): converting separate property into HUF property
This rule applies where an individual converts owned property into the property of an HUF of which the individual is a member, without adequate consideration. It identifies three modes: impressing the property with family-property character; throwing it into the family’s common stock; or transferring it directly or indirectly to the family. The rule operates despite other provisions of this Act or another law for this income computation. S1, section 99(3)(a)–(c)
Under clause (i), the individual is deemed to have transferred the property through the family to its members for joint holding, and income from that property or part is deemed to be the individual’s income. Under clause (ii), following a partial or total partition, income from the converted property received by the spouse on partition is treated as arising from assets indirectly transferred to the spouse, attracting subsection (1)(a). The closing words exclude the income from the HUF’s or spouse’s total income once included in the individual’s, avoiding duplicate inclusion under this mechanism. S1, section 99(3)(i)–(ii) and concluding words
The partition clause is not a universal recognition of every partial partition for all tax purposes. Section 315 separately governs HUF partition assessment and includes its own partial-partition rule. The particular event must satisfy the relevant provisions rather than relying on section 99 alone. S1, sections 99(3)(ii) and 315
Sections 99(4) and (5)(c)–(d): date, substitute assets and losses
Subsection (4) excludes from subsection (3) conversions made on or before 31 December 1969. It is a historical cut-off for that HUF rule, not a general exemption for all old family property. S1, section 99(4)
For subsection (3), property includes an interest in property, movable and immovable assets, sale proceeds and money/property/investments representing those proceeds, and substitute property obtained by any conversion method. Selling or replacing the converted property therefore does not automatically erase the tracing rule. S1, section 99(5)(c)(i)–(iv)
For the whole section, income includes loss. Clubbing is not limited to profitable outcomes. However, the separate head-wise restrictions on set-off and carry-forward still need to be applied; a clubbed capital loss does not thereby become deductible against any income the individual chooses. S1, section 99(5)(d), Chapter VII
Hypothetical illustrations
Gift receipt excluded, interest included with donor
Facts: An individual gifts ₹10 lakh to a spouse, who earns ₹70,000 interest on it in tax year 2026–27.
Assumptions: The transfer is without adequate consideration and not under an agreement to live apart. All ₹70,000 is traceable to the gifted money.
Question: Does the relative-gift exclusion make the interest tax-free?
Analysis: Section 92(3)(a) addresses the gift receipt. Section 99(1)(a)(ii) separately includes income from the transferred asset with the transferor.
Conclusion: The ₹70,000 interest is included in the donor’s total income, subject to the applicable computation rules. S1
Mixed capital in a spouse’s business
Facts: On 1 April 2026 a spouse has ₹4 lakh of covered gifted assets invested in a business and ₹10 lakh total investment. The relevant business income for tax year 2026–27 is ₹2 lakh.
Assumptions: The figures meet the meanings of B, C and D in subsection (2). No separate exemption, loss adjustment or special allocation affects B.
Question: How much does the statutory ratio include with the transferor?
Analysis: A = ₹2,00,000 × (₹4,00,000 ÷ ₹10,00,000) = ₹80,000. The fraction is 40%.
Conclusion: ₹80,000 is included with the transferor; the remaining ₹1,20,000 is outside this particular allocation. S1, S4
Minor-child interest under two regimes
Facts: A minor has ₹10,000 bank interest in tax year 2026–27. Parent A’s pre-inclusion income is ₹9 lakh and Parent B’s is ₹6 lakh.
Assumptions: The marriage subsists and this is the first relevant inclusion year. No work, skill or disability exception applies.
Question: Which parent includes it, and is ₹1,500 always excluded?
Analysis: Parent A has the greater pre-inclusion income. Outside section 202(1), Schedule III item 17 excludes ₹1,500, leaving ₹8,500. Under section 202(1), section 202(2)(a)(i) denies that exclusion.
Conclusion: Parent A includes ₹8,500 after the eligible exclusion in the first case, or ₹10,000 in the section 202(1) case. S1
Professional work by a spouse
Facts: For an illustrative event under the operative provisions in tax year 2026–27: A qualified engineer is paid for engineering work by a company in which the engineer’s spouse has the required substantial interest.
Assumptions: The remuneration is solely attributable to application of the engineer’s relevant professional knowledge, experience and qualification. The facts substantiate the work rather than a nominal appointment.
Question: Does the shareholding connection alone require clubbing?
Analysis: Clause (1)(a)(i) expressly excludes the described professional income. The substantial-interest condition does not erase that exception.
Conclusion: The remuneration is not included under this clause on the assumed facts; it remains subject to the engineer’s own tax computation. S1
Separate investment property put into the HUF pool
Facts: In 2026 an individual member transfers a personally owned investment to the HUF’s common stock without adequate consideration. It earns ₹50,000 in tax year 2026–27.
Assumptions: The income is entirely from the converted investment. The conversion falls after the historical cut-off.
Question: Does the HUF’s receipt of the income decide who includes it?
Analysis: Subsection (3)(b) covers the common-stock conversion and clause (i) attributes the property income to the individual. The concluding words prevent duplicate inclusion with the HUF.
Conclusion: ₹50,000 is included with the individual under section 99(3), not duplicated in the HUF under this rule. S1
Reader questions
Is every adult child’s income clubbed with a parent?
No. The minor-child clause concerns minors. A separate clause may apply to a particular transfer or arrangement, but section 99 does not create a blanket rule for all adult children’s independent income. S1
Can parents switch the minor’s income every year to save tax?
No. Section 99(5)(b) contains a continuity rule and requires the Assessing Officer’s satisfaction after a hearing opportunity for the other parent before a later switch. S1
Does the gift-relative definition control substantial interest?
Do not assume so. Section 99’s substantial-interest provision must be read with the applicable general definition in section 2(94), while section 92(5)(g) supplies a specific, wider definition for its own gift rule. S1
Does converting an asset into another asset stop the HUF rule?
Not by itself. Section 99(5)(c) expressly includes sale proceeds, investments representing them and substitute property for subsection (3). S1