At a glance
| Item | Position |
|---|---|
| Act and provision | Income-tax Act, 2025, section 98 |
| Official heading | “Transfer” and “revocable transfer” defined. |
| Location | Chapter V: Income of other persons included in total income of assessee |
| Legal status | Enacted and operative; editorial draft |
| General commencement | 1 April 2026 |
| Legal function | Scoped definitions for income attribution |
The definitions have a specific statutory job
Section 98 opens by limiting its definitions to sections 96 and 97 and itself. Section 96 attributes assigned income to a transferor who retains its source asset. Section 97 deals with income from revocably transferred assets and contains a limited exception. Section 98 helps determine whether the relevant arrangement and retained rights fall within those rules. It is definitional, not a standalone tax-rate or penalty provision. S1, sections 96–98
The Act also uses transfer in other contexts, including capital gains. Do not replace those provisions’ definitions or exclusions with section 98 merely because the same English word appears. A transaction’s classification for one purpose need not answer every other tax question. S1, section 98, opening words; sections 2(109), 67 and 70
Clause (a): transfer includes several forms of arrangement
Transfer includes any settlement, trust, covenant, agreement or arrangement. The inclusive wording reaches beyond a formal sale or gift. A covenant is, in plain language, a binding promise; the exact legal effect of a particular covenant still depends on its terms. The list is not confined to documents with a title such as transfer deed. S1, section 98(a)
This matters when a taxpayer directs an income stream through an agreement while leaving the source asset unchanged. Such an arrangement can still be a transfer for section 96. Where the asset itself is conveyed, the instrument must also be examined under clause (b) and section 97. The name chosen by the parties is evidence of neither complete ownership transfer nor irrevocability by itself. S1, sections 96–98
Clause (b)(i): a provision for retransfer
A transfer is deemed revocable if it contains any provision for direct or indirect retransfer of all or part of the income or assets to the transferor. Income and assets are alternatives: a return right over income can matter even if the legal title to the asset never comes back. Likewise, a partial return right is not outside the wording. S1, section 98(b)(i)
The test concerns a provision in the transfer, not only a retransfer already completed. Read connected instruments where they define the arrangement’s rights; an indirect path does not escape the wording merely because another person or entity stands between the transferor and the asset. Whether a particular chain supplies such a provision requires the actual documents and facts. S1, section 98(b)(i)
Clause (b)(ii): a right to reassume power
A transfer is also deemed revocable if it gives the transferor a right, in any way, to reassume power directly or indirectly over all or part of the income or assets. This alternative looks at retained power rather than requiring a formal right to recover title. Either this test or the retransfer test can apply. S1, section 98(b)(ii)
A review should distinguish actual legal rights from an unsupported assumption that the transferor remains influential. Not every administrative role necessarily grants a personal right to reassume power; equally, calling a retained power administrative does not settle the issue. Examine the scope, beneficiary, conditions and enforceability of the power rather than deciding solely from a job title such as trustee. This is a document-analysis approach derived from the statutory right-based test. S1, section 98(b)(ii)
Deemed revocability is followed by the section 97 analysis
Once clause (b) is engaged, apply section 97 rather than treating section 98 as the final computation. Section 97(2) can exclude its ordinary rule where the transfer is not revocable during the relevant beneficiary’s or transferee’s lifetime and the transferor derives no direct or indirect benefit from the income. Section 97(3) restores attribution when the power to revoke arises. The definition and the exception work together. S1, sections 97(1)–(3) and 98(b)
The references to any part in section 98 define the breadth of the trigger. They are not an express percentage formula saying that only that percentage of income is included. Identify the relevant transfer and then apply section 97’s income language. Complex arrangements containing separate assets or severable rights should not be resolved by inventing a simple allocation percentage. S1, sections 97(1) and 98(b)
Hypothetical illustrations
Income can return even when asset title cannot
Facts: A deed transfers an investment to another adult but allows the transferor to require one-quarter of its annual income to be returned on demand throughout tax year 2026–27.
Assumptions: The return right is enforceable and forms part of the transfer. The lifetime exception is not satisfied.
Question: Is the absence of a right to recover the investment enough to avoid clause (b)(i)?
Analysis: No. The clause expressly covers a provision for retransfer of part of the income, not only the entire asset.
Conclusion: The transfer is deemed revocable; section 97 must then be applied. One-quarter is not automatically the taxable fraction merely because that is the retained return right. S1
A definition without an automatic tax charge
Facts: For an illustrative event under the operative provisions in tax year 2026–27: An agreement genuinely transfers an asset outright to an unrelated adult, with no direct or indirect return provision and no retained right to reassume power.
Assumptions: The arrangement contains no connected contrary terms.
Question: Does the agreement’s inclusion in clause (a) alone make it revocable?
Analysis: Clause (a) recognises it as a transfer, but the distinct facts required by clause (b)(i) or (ii) are absent on these assumptions.
Conclusion: Calling it a transfer under section 98 does not by itself trigger the revocable-transfer income rule. S1
Reader questions
Must a document use the word revocable?
No. Clause (b) applies its substantive tests to return provisions and retained rights regardless of the document’s label. S1
Does being a trustee automatically establish a right to reassume power?
The section asks what rights the transfer gives the transferor. The actual deed and associated powers must be examined; the title alone does not establish either answer. S1