At a glance
| Item | Position |
|---|---|
| Act and provision | Income-tax Act, 2025, section 91 |
| Official heading | Reference to Valuation Officer. |
| Location | Chapter IV, Part E: Capital gains |
| Legal status | Enacted and operative; editorial draft |
| General commencement | 1 April 2026 |
| Legal function | Valuation reference and procedural safeguards |
What is being valued, and why?
The opening words concern fair market value of a capital asset for Chapter IV. The provision sits in the capital-gains part of that Chapter, but its language says “this Chapter”; it should not be rewritten as an independent power to tax every difference in value. The relevant charging or computation provision must first explain why fair market value matters. For example, section 90 can make historical fair market value relevant to the cost of an eligible pre-1 April 2001 asset. The valuation date and legal purpose must therefore be identified before comparing numbers. S1, sections 91(1) and 90(9)
The Assessing Officer decides whether to refer. The Valuation Officer is a government-appointed statutory officer, defined in section 2(110). A privately engaged registered valuer supports the taxpayer’s valuation; that report is not the same as the statutory officer’s report. S1, sections 2(110), 91 and 513
Section 91(1)(a): a registered valuer’s estimate
If the taxpayer’s claimed value follows a registered valuer’s estimate, the Assessing Officer may refer when he considers that value to be at variance with fair market value. The wording is not confined to undervaluation. An inflated historical cost valuation, as well as an understated value, can therefore fall within this limb. The percentage and rupee limits in clause (b)(i) are not conditions written into clause (a). A valuation report does not make the claimed figure immune from scrutiny. S1, section 91(1)(a)
Section 91(1)(b): two routes in other cases
Where clause (a) does not apply, clause (b) supplies alternatives. Under sub-clause (i), the Assessing Officer must consider fair market value to exceed the claimed value by more than the prescribed percentage or amount. Rule 55 prescribes 15% and ₹10 lakh. Read with the statutory “or”, exceeding either benchmark satisfies this numerical route; exceeding both is unnecessary. Equality with a benchmark is not “more than” that benchmark. S1, section 91(1)(b)(i); S2, rule 55
Under sub-clause (ii), a reference can instead be necessary having regard to the nature of the asset and other relevant circumstances. Consequently the numerical tests are not a universal safe harbour against any reference. The two routes should be kept distinct: a numerical shortfall does not answer whether the second route is justified by the asset and circumstances. S1, section 91(1)(b)(ii)
Section 91(2): evidence, inspection and two hearing stages
Section 91(2) imports section 269(3)–(8), with necessary modifications. These provisions perform different functions:
- Subsection (3) permits relevant entry, inspection, surveying and examination of valuation records. Entry into premises under clause (a)(ii), and inspection under clause (a)(iii), require the specified consent and at least two days’ written notice. Refusal or evasion can lead to the listed civil-court powers, including attendance, document production and commissions.
- Subsection (4) requires consideration of the taxpayer’s evidence and other gathered evidence after an opportunity of hearing.
- Subsection (5) permits a best-judgment estimate if the taxpayer does not cooperate or follow directions.
- Subsection (6) requires the report to go to both the Assessing Officer and taxpayer.
- Subsection (7) permits rectification of an apparent mistake under section 287.
- Subsection (8) gives a further opportunity of hearing before the Assessing Officer takes the report into account in assessment or reassessment. S1, sections 91(2) and 269(3)–(8)
Rule 174 specifies inspection between 6 a.m. and 6 p.m. on days other than public holidays; Sundays are included in public holidays. This timing rule does not remove the Act’s applicable notice and consent protections. S2, rule 174
Section 91 expressly imports subsections (3)–(8), not subsection (9). The six-month report period in section 269(9), framed for a reference under section 269(1), should not automatically be presented as a deadline imposed by section 91 itself. S1, sections 91(2) and 269(9)
Which officer, and what should the taxpayer retain?
Rule 173 ordinarily allocates valuation work by whole-asset value: above ₹5 crore to the District Valuation Officer; above ₹1 crore and up to ₹5 crore to the Valuation Officer; and up to ₹1 crore to the Assistant Valuation Officer. For a section 91 reference, the relevant allocation value is the taxpayer’s claimed value. Joint ownership does not reduce the asset’s whole value for this allocation. The rule also permits specified higher officers to undertake lower-band work. These are allocation rules, not exemptions from valuation. S2, rule 173
As practical preparation, retain the valuation report, acquisition documents, comparable transactions, plans, restrictions affecting use, and evidence tied to the correct valuation date. Identify disagreements with the report separately from disagreements about the tax provision that makes valuation relevant. The statutory hearing rights are most useful when objections explain the asset, date, assumptions and evidence rather than merely insisting on the original figure. This is practical guidance derived from the evidence-and-hearing procedure. S1, section 269(4) and (8)
Hypothetical illustrations
One numerical benchmark is enough
Facts: For a tax-year 2026–27 computation, an asset’s claimed value is ₹2 crore and the Assessing Officer considers fair market value to be ₹2.12 crore. No registered valuer’s estimate supports the claim.
Assumptions: The relevant computation law calls for this fair market value. The figures are hypothetical; no tax rate is assumed.
Question: Does clause (b)(i) permit a reference?
Analysis: The difference is ₹12 lakh. It is 6% of ₹2 crore, below 15%, but exceeds ₹10 lakh. The alternative rupee benchmark is crossed.
Conclusion: The numerical ground is available; the reference does not itself determine taxable income. S1, S2
A higher registered valuation is not protected
Facts: For an illustrative event under the operative provisions in tax year 2026–27: An eligible old asset has a claimed historical fair market value of ₹80 lakh supported by a registered valuer. The Assessing Officer considers the correct historical value to be ₹70 lakh.
Assumptions: The relevant historical valuation date and cost option under section 90 apply.
Question: Can clause (a) apply when the taxpayer’s value is higher?
Analysis: The claimed estimate differs from the fair market value considered appropriate by the officer. Clause (a) uses variance, not only an excess of fair market value over the claim.
Conclusion: A reference can be made under clause (a), subject to the imported procedure. S1
Reader questions
Does a valuation reference prove concealment?
No. Section 91 creates a reference mechanism. Any addition, interest or penalty needs its own legal basis and relevant findings; the referral alone establishes none of them. S1
Can I challenge the official report before it is used?
Section 269(8), imported by section 91(2), requires the Assessing Officer to give an opportunity of hearing before taking the report into account. Section 269(4) separately provides a hearing during valuation. S1