At a glance
| Item | Position |
|---|---|
| Act and provision | Income-tax Act, 2025, section 80 |
| Official heading | Fair market value deemed to be full value of consideration in certain cases. |
| Location | Chapter IV, Part E: Capital gains |
| Legal status | Enacted and operative; editorial draft |
| General commencement | 1 April 2026 |
| Legal function | Consideration substitution where the amount cannot be determined |
The trigger is genuine inability to determine consideration
Section 80 applies where consideration received or accruing from transfer of a capital asset is not ascertainable or cannot be determined. The issue is whether the amount can be determined, not simply whether it has already been paid. A fixed contractual receivable can remain ascertainable despite delayed payment. Similarly, a low price is not inherently indeterminate; sections 78 and 79 contain separate undervalue rules for their specified assets. S1, sections 80, 78 and 79
Noncash consideration is not automatically unascertainable either: first examine whether it can be valued under the relevant contract and statutory framework. An earn-out or contingent-price clause needs its own analysis as at transfer; neither every contingency nor every uncertainty justifies assuming this section applies. Establish the enforceable consideration mechanism and record why it does or does not yield a determinable amount. S1, section 80
Value the asset transferred on the transfer date
Once triggered, the section deems the fair market value of the transferred capital asset on the date of transfer to be full consideration. It does not say to use its value when payment finally arrives, or automatically the value of a different asset received in exchange. Section 2(44) supplies the Act’s FMV definition: ordinarily the open-market price on the relevant date, with the prescribed route where that price is not ascertainable. S1, sections 80 and 2(44)
A supported valuation should identify the asset and rights actually transferred, the date, relevant market evidence and the method’s factual assumptions. The special slump-sale formula in Rule 53 and the specific share methods are not freely interchangeable universal formulas for every section 80 asset. Use an applicable prescribed method where one exists; do not invent a zero value simply because the consideration is uncertain. S1, sections 2(44), 77(3)(b), 79(1) and 80
Assessment valuation powers are a separate procedure
Section 91 permits an Assessing Officer’s reference for capital-gain valuation in the specified circumstances. Where the claimed value follows a registered-valuer estimate, the test is whether it is at variance with FMV. In the other specified case, Rule 55 prescribes the thresholds: FMV must exceed the claimed value by more than 15% of that value or more than ₹10 lakh, and section 91 also provides the separate nature-of-asset/relevant-circumstances route. These are not a section 80 exemption or a 15% price safe harbour. S1, section 91(1)(a)–(b); S2, rule 55
The reference procedure imports section 269(3)–(8), with necessary modifications. A valuation report must be considered through the applicable statutory process, rather than treated as an unexplained numerical substitute. These procedural powers do not change section 80’s transfer-date substantive test. S1, section 91(2), section 269(3)–(8)
Complete the gain calculation after substitution
The deemed FMV is the consideration input for income under capital gains. The applicable section 72 expenses and acquisition/improvement cost rules still need to be applied. Section 80 supplies no independent flat rate, holding period or exemption. First also establish that the transaction is chargeable: a qualifying exclusion under section 70 is not automatically defeated merely because a gift has no stated cash price. S1, sections 67, 70, 72 and 80
Hypothetical illustrations
An unpaid fixed price is still a price
Facts: A capital asset is transferred in 2026–27 for an enforceable fixed ₹10 lakh consideration, payable later.
Assumptions: No clause makes the amount contingent or indeterminate. No separate deemed-consideration provision changes the price.
Question: Does delayed payment alone trigger section 80?
Analysis: No. The fixed ₹10 lakh can be ascertained even though collection is later.
Conclusion: Timing of receipt and ability to determine consideration are different questions. S1
A genuinely indeterminate consideration
Facts: In a chargeable 2026–27 transfer, consideration cannot be ascertained or determined. The transferred asset’s supported transfer-date FMV is ₹50 lakh, allowable cost ₹20 lakh and qualifying transfer expenditure ₹1 lakh.
Assumptions: Section 80’s trigger is established from the actual contract. No special cost, valuation, exemption or indexation rule changes these inputs.
Question: What capital gain follows?
Analysis: Substitute ₹50 lakh as consideration: ₹50 lakh−₹20 lakh−₹1 lakh = ₹29 lakh.
Conclusion: The gain is ₹29 lakh, not the entire ₹50 lakh FMV. S1
Reader questions
Does every noncash exchange automatically come under section 80?
No. Determine whether consideration can be ascertained and whether another specific provision applies. S1
Which date supplies the fair market value?
The date of transfer of the capital asset, as expressly stated in section 80. S1