At a glance
| Item | Position |
|---|---|
| Act and provision | Income-tax Act, 2025, section 79 |
| Official heading | Special provision for full value of consideration for transfer of share other than quoted share. |
| Location | Chapter IV, Part E: Capital gains |
| Legal status | Enacted and operative; editorial draft |
| General commencement | 1 April 2026 |
| Legal function | Deemed consideration for specified company shares |
The asset, transfer and undervalue tests
Subsection (1) requires transfer of a capital asset that is a company share other than a quoted share. If consideration is less than prescribed FMV, FMV becomes consideration for section 72. It is not a general rule for every bond or every business inventory item merely because Rule 57 also values other securities. Establish capital-asset status, transfer, relevant share category and prescribed value separately. S1, section 79(1)
There is no express 110% safe harbour here. That tolerance belongs to section 78 for the specified capital property. If actual consideration equals or exceeds prescribed FMV, subsection (1)’s below-value trigger is not met. Cost and allowable transfer expenses are then addressed under section 72; substituted consideration is not the same as taxable profit. S1, sections 72, 78(1)(b) and 79(1)
Quoted is more specific than merely listed
A quoted share is quoted on a recognised stock exchange with regularity from time to time, with quotations based on current ordinary-course transactions. A listing label alone does not establish all these elements. Thin trading or stale quotations call for a factual examination, rather than an automatic conclusion either way. Rule 56 contains related quoted/unquoted definitions for valuation. S1, section 79(3); S2, rule 56(c), (h)
Read the valuation provisions together, preserving their wording
Rule 56(i), Table row 2, expressly fixes the section 79 valuation date as the share-transfer date. The notified Rule 57, Table rows 4–5, prints sections 26(2)(j), 72 and 92 in its section column, rather than naming section 79. Section 79(1), in turn, expressly makes its substitution for section 72 purposes. These texts support reading the Rule 57 share-valuation methods together with the section 79-to-72 computation, but that linkage is an interpretation of the provisions read together, not a claim that the Gazette prints “79”. S1, section 79(1); S2, rules 56(i) and 57, Table rows 4–5
The valuation explanation below uses that linked reading. The printed cross-reference should be checked against any later authoritative clarification when applying the provision to a real transfer; it has not been silently rewritten. This qualification does not alter the clear statutory below-FMV trigger, transfer-date rule or prescribed-exception analysis. S1, section 79; S2, rules 56–58
Unquoted equity: the adjusted asset-value formula
Rule 57 row 4 gives FMV = (A+B+C+D−L)×PV/PE. PV is paid-up value of the equity share or shares being valued; PE is total paid-up equity capital in the balance sheet. Keep the share-count basis consistent: a per-share PV produces a per-share value, whereas aggregate PV produces the value of the corresponding holding. S2, rule 57, Table row 4
A is book value of assets excluding jewellery, art, shares, securities and immovable property, less tax paid net of refund claimed and book amounts that do not represent an asset’s value, including relevant unamortised deferred expenditure. B is jewellery/art open-market value supported by a registered-valuer report. C is shares/securities value determined under Rule 57. D is immovable-property stamp duty value. S2, rule 57, Table row 4, A–D
L excludes paid-up equity capital; provisions for dividends not declared before transfer at a general body meeting; reserves and surplus, including negative balances, other than depreciation reserves; the specified excess tax provision over book-profit tax, with the adjustment for tax paid net of refund claimed; unascertained-liability provisions; and contingent liabilities other than cumulative-preference-dividend arrears. Simply using the financial statements’ total liabilities can therefore undervalue the shares. S2, rule 57, Table row 4, L
Rule 56(a) requires the valuation-date balance sheet with its notes, audited under the relevant company-law framework; for a non-Indian company it uses the auditor, if any, appointed under that country’s law. A stale annual balance sheet or an elective discounted-cash-flow figure is not automatically interchangeable with this prescribed equity formula. S2, rules 56(a) and 57, Table row 4
Non-equity unquoted shares use the separate category
Rule 57 row 5 concerns the stated unquoted shares and securities other than company equity shares that are not listed on a recognised exchange. It uses the price they would fetch on the open market on the valuation date, and permits a report from a merchant banker or accountant. Rule 56(b) identifies the merchant banker as a SEBI-registered Category I merchant banker. For section 79, the underlying asset must still be a company share: the rule’s mention of securities does not expand the section to all instruments. Also check the row’s listing condition rather than assuming every share failing the section 79 quoted test necessarily falls in row 5. S1, section 79(1); S2, rules 56(b) and 57, Table row 5
The narrow prescribed exception
Subsection (2) allows prescribed classes and conditions. Rule 58(2) extends only the transaction in Rule 58(1), Table row 2, to section 79. That row requires a Tribunal, on a Central Government application under Companies Act section 241, to suspend the company’s board and appoint Government-nominated directors under section 242. The relevant company/subsidiary/sub-subsidiary shares must be received by the shareholder pursuant to a Tribunal-approved section 242 resolution plan after the jurisdictional Principal Commissioner or Commissioner has a reasonable opportunity to be heard. S1, section 79(2); S2, rule 58(1), Table row 2 and rule 58(2)
For this rule, a subsidiary requires more than half of nominal equity-share capital to be held by the other company; exactly half is insufficient. “Tribunal” follows Companies Act section 2(90). The other Rule 58(1) categories for section 92 are not all automatically imported into section 79: subsection (2) of the rule singles out row 2. Preserve the Government application, Tribunal orders, approved plan, ownership chain and hearing evidence. S2, rule 58(2), (3)(b)
Seller and recipient consequences remain separate
Section 79 changes the transferor’s consideration. A recipient’s possible section 92(2)(m) charge has its own conditions and exclusions. Likewise, section 73(1), Table row 17, gives its cost consequence where the property value has been subjected to that receipt-side tax. A seller’s FMV substitution alone does not prove the buyer is entitled to the same enhanced cost. S1, sections 79, 92(2)(m) and 73(1), Table row 17
Hypothetical illustrations
Apply the equity fraction consistently
Facts: For a hypothetical 2026–27 transfer, adjusted A is ₹60 lakh, B nil, C ₹10 lakh, D ₹40 lakh and eligible L ₹10 lakh. Total paid-up equity capital is ₹1 lakh and each share has ₹10 paid up. 1,000 shares sell for ₹7 lakh; cost is ₹4 lakh and qualifying expense ₹10,000.
Assumptions: The transfer falls within section 79 and no Rule 58 exception applies. The Rule 57 linked reading explained above applies, and all inputs use the transfer date.
Question: What does the valuation and gain calculation produce?
Analysis: Adjusted net assets = ₹100 lakh. Per-share FMV = ₹100 lakh×₹10/₹1 lakh = ₹1,000. For 1,000 shares, FMV is ₹10 lakh, above ₹7 lakh actual consideration. Gain = ₹10 lakh−₹4 lakh−₹0.1 lakh = ₹5.9 lakh.
Conclusion: The fraction must be applied once; do not multiply an already aggregate holding value by share count again. S1, S2
Reader questions
Does being listed automatically establish quoted-share status?
No. Section 79(3) also requires regular quotations grounded in current ordinary-course transactions. S1
Do all Rule 58 exemptions apply to this section?
No. Rule 58(2) imports the property and conditions of Table row 2 for section 79. S1, S2