At-a-Glance Summary
| Attribute | Verified Legal Position |
|---|---|
| Act Name | Income-tax Act, 2025 (Act No. 30 of 2025) S2 |
| Section Number | Section 490 S1 |
| Official Heading | Presumption as to culpable mental state. S1 |
| Chapter | Chapter XXII - Offences and Prosecutions S1 |
| Section Category | Penalty, prosecution, or enforcement S1 |
| Legal Status | Enacted on 21 August 2025; in force from 1 April 2026 (as amended by Finance Act, 2026) S1, S2 |
| Applicable Period | Tax Year 2026-27 (beginning 1 April 2026) onwards, subject to Section 536 transition rules S2, S3 |
| 1961 Act Counterpart | Section 278E of the Income-tax Act, 1961 S1, S2 |
Legal Function and Scope of Section 490
Section 490 of the Income-tax Act, 2025—titled "Presumption as to culpable mental state."—forms part of Chapter XXII - Offences and Prosecutions S1. While the Income-tax Act, 2025 received Presidential assent on 21 August 2025 as Act No. 30 of 2025, Section 1(3) postponed its general commencement to 1 April 2026 S2, section 1(3). Accordingly, Section 490 is operative law across the whole of India from 1 April 2026 (Tax Year 2026-27 onwards), replacing Section 278E of the Income-tax Act, 1961 subject to the repeal and savings framework in Section 536 S1, S2, S3.
Provision-by-Provision Analysis of Section 490
Every sub-section, clause, and material condition enacted in Section 490 is examined below in its statutory sequence S1:
Mandatory Rebuttable Presumption of Culpable Mental State (Section 490(1))
Section 490(1): In any prosecution for any offence under this Act which requires a culpable mental state on the part of the accused, the court shall presume the existence of such mental state but it shall be a defence for the accused to prove the fact that he had no such mental state with respect to the act charged as an offence in that prosecution. S1.
Key statutory conditions, parameters, and exceptions under this provision include:
- Uses the mandatory command 'the court shall presume' (not merely 'may presume'). S1.
- Applies to any offence under Chapter XXII that requires a mental element (such as 'fraudulently' in Sec. 475, 'wilfully' in Secs. 478/479/480/481/483, or 'knows or believes to be false' in Secs. 482/483/484). S1.
- Preserves the accused's right to prove the absence of such mental state as a complete defence. S1.
Statutory Definition of 'Culpable Mental State' (Section 490(2))
Section 490(2): In this section, 'culpable mental state' includes intention, motive or knowledge of a fact or belief in, or reason to believe, a fact. S1.
Key statutory conditions, parameters, and exceptions under this provision include:
- Exhaustively covers every species of mens rea used across Chapter XXII: intention, motive, knowledge of a fact, belief in a fact, and reason to believe a fact. S1.
'Beyond Reasonable Doubt' Standard for Proving Absence of Mental State (Section 490(3))
Section 490(3): For the purposes of this section, a fact is said to be proved only when the court believes it to exist beyond reasonable doubt and not merely when its existence is established by a preponderance of probability. S1.
Key statutory conditions, parameters, and exceptions under this provision include:
- Departs from the ordinary rule in general evidence law (where an accused can rebut a statutory presumption on a preponderance of probability). S1.
- Requires the accused to establish the absence of culpable mental state to the degree that the court believes its non-existence beyond reasonable doubt (either from admissions elicited in cross-examination of prosecution witnesses or from unimpeachable defence evidence/official records). S1.
Key Legal Terms and Definitions
To read Section 490 accurately, readers should distinguish between terms defined within Section 490 itself, terms imported from other provisions, and explanatory descriptions S1, S2:
| Term / Expression | Statutory Source Basis | Plain-Language Explanation |
|---|---|---|
| Culpable mental state | Defined in Section 490(2) | Includes intention, motive, or knowledge of a fact, or belief in, or reason to believe, a fact. S1, S2 |
| Beyond reasonable doubt vs. Preponderance of probability | Stated in Section 490(3) | Section 490(3) elevates the threshold of proof for the defence under Section 490(1) from 'more likely than not' (preponderance of probability) to 'proved beyond reasonable doubt'. S1, S2 |
Practical Application and Compliance Impact
Section 490 is the pivot on which every criminal trial under Sections 475, 478, 479, 480, 481, 482, 483, and 484 turns S1, S2:
- How Section 490 Operates in Practice: Suppose an assessee files a return omitting ₹80 lakh of capital gains (
Section 478(1)/Section 482), or fails to file a return by the due date (Section 479). Once the Income-tax Department proves the foundational fact that the gain was omitted or the return was not filed in time, the Department does not have to lead separate affirmative evidence of what was inside the taxpayer's mind—Section 490(1) requires the court to presume that the omission or non-filing was wilful and knowing S1. - How an Accused Successfully Rebuts Section 490(3): Even under the strict 'beyond reasonable doubt' standard of Section 490(3), an accused does not necessarily have to step into the witness box; they can prove the absence of culpable mental state from undisputed official records, contemporaneous correspondence, medical records, audit working papers, or cross-examination of departmental witnesses (for example, showing that the capital asset was disclosed in the balance sheet notes or that an application for extension/copies of seized records was pending before the AO) S1.
Statutory Boundaries, Conditions, and Exceptions
Author analysis based on the statutory text of Section 490 and related provisions S1, S2:
- Does Not Relieve Prosecution From Proving the Foundational Act (Actus Reus): Section 490 only presumes the mental state (
mens rea). The prosecution must still prove every physical/factual ingredient of the offence (actus reus) beyond reasonable doubt S1. - Interaction With Section 486 (TDS/TCS Reasonable Cause): Notice the difference between Section 486 and Section 490. Offences under Sections 476 and 477 (non-payment of TDS/TCS) are governed by the specific 'reasonable cause' defence in Section 486, which does not contain a 'beyond reasonable doubt' clause like Section 490(3) S1, S2.
Related Provisions and Cross-References
Section 490 must be read harmoniously with the following provisions (with the governing Act explicitly identified for each section number) S1, S2, S3:
| Legislation | Provision Reference | Relationship to Section 490 |
|---|---|---|
| Income-tax Act, 2025 | Sections 473, 474, 475, 478, 479, 480, 481, 482, 483, and 484 | Offence provisions in Chapter XXII whose mental element ('wilfully', 'fraudulently', 'knows to be false') is governed by Section 490. S1, S2 |
| Income-tax Act, 2025 | Section 489 | Companion evidentiary presumption regarding assets, books, documents, and electronic records found in search or requisition. S2 |
| Income-tax Act, 2025 | Section 491 | Requires prior administrative sanction before instituting prosecution and provides for compounding of offences. S2, S8 |
| Income-tax Act, 1961 | Section 278E | Corresponding provision in the repealed 1961 Act. S1, S2 |
Transition and Comparison with the Income-tax Act, 1961
Section 490 corresponds verbatim to Section 278E of the repealed Income-tax Act, 1961 (whose constitutional validity was upheld by the Supreme Court of India in Sasi Enterprises v. ACIT and Prakash Nath Khanna v. CIT) S1, S2.
Distinction Between 'Tax Year', 'Previous Year', and 'Assessment Year': Under the repealed Income-tax Act, 1961, income earned in a 'previous year' (financial year) was taxed in the following 'assessment year'. Under Section 3 of the Income-tax Act, 2025, that dual terminology is replaced from 1 April 2026 by a single 'tax year' (the 12-month period beginning on 1st April) S2, section 3. Under Section 536(3) of the 2025 Act, any reference to a tax year commencing on or before 1 April 2025 is construed as a reference to the corresponding 'previous year' under the repealed 1961 Act S3, section 536(3).
Hypothetical Illustrations
The following examples are hypothetical scenarios designed to illustrate the operation of Section 490 S1:
Illustration EX1: Operation of Presumption in a Section 479 Prosecution for Non-Filing of Return (Hypothetical)
- Facts: In a prosecution under Section 479(1)(a) against a businessman who failed to file his return under Section 268(1) despite having ₹70 lakh of taxable tax liability, the prosecution proves service of the Section 268(1) notice and non-filing of the return within the stipulated time. The businessman argues that the case must be dismissed because the Assessing Officer did not lead independent evidence proving that his state of mind was 'wilful'.
- Assumptions: The businessman leads no defence evidence and brings nothing on record in cross-examination to explain why the return was not filed.
- Legal Question: Is the businessman's argument valid in light of Section 490?
- Analysis: Under Section 490(1) and (2), in any prosecution for an offence requiring a culpable mental state (such as 'wilfully' in Section 479(1)), the court shall presume the existence of such mental state, and the burden lies on the accused to prove that he had no such mental state beyond reasonable doubt (
Section 490(3)) S1. - Conclusion: No. Once service of notice and failure to file are proved, the court must presume under Section 490(1) that the failure was wilful unless the accused proves otherwise beyond reasonable doubt.
Illustration EX2: Rebutting the Presumption Beyond Reasonable Doubt Through Undisputed Official Records (Hypothetical)
- Facts: An assessee is prosecuted under Section 482 for a 'false verification' because her return showed bank interest of ₹1,85,000 instead of ₹8,15,000. In trial, she produces the undisputed original interest certificate issued by the nationalised bank (which itself had printed '₹1,85,000' due to a bank software bug and was rectified by the bank only a year later) and shows that she had attached that exact bank certificate to her computation.
- Assumptions: The bank's erroneous certificate and subsequent rectification letter are undisputed official records proved in trial.
- Legal Question: Has the assessee discharged the burden under Section 490(1) and (3)?
- Analysis: The undisputed bank certificate proves beyond reasonable doubt (
Section 490(3)) that at the time of verifying her return, the assessee believed the figure of ₹1,85,000 to be true based on the bank's own certificate and had no knowledge or belief that it was false (Section 490(1)–(2)) S1. - Conclusion: Yes. The assessee has proved the absence of a culpable mental state beyond reasonable doubt under Section 490(1) and (3), entitling her to acquittal.
Common Misconceptions and Legal Corrections
-
Misconception 1: "In a criminal tax trial, the Income-tax Department must independently prove 'wilful intent' from the outset without any help from a statutory presumption."
- Legal Correction: Section 490(1) explicitly reverses the burden on mens rea: once the foundational act/omission is proved, 'the court shall presume the existence of such mental state' S1.
-
Misconception 2: "An accused can rebut the presumption in Section 490(1) merely by raising a plausible theory on a preponderance of probability."
- Legal Correction: Section 490(3) expressly mandates that for the purposes of Section 490, a fact is said to be proved only when the court believes it to exist beyond reasonable doubt and not merely when its existence is established by a preponderance of probability S1.
Reader Questions (FAQs)
What does 'culpable mental state' include under Section 490(2)?
Under Section 490(2), 'culpable mental state' includes intention, motive, or knowledge of a fact, or belief in, or reason to believe, a fact S1.
Does Section 490 mean that every prosecution results in automatic conviction?
No. First, the prosecution must still prove the foundational act or omission beyond reasonable doubt. Second, the accused can prove the absence of culpable mental state under Section 490(1) using official records, contemporaneous correspondence, or admissions elicited during cross-examination of prosecution witnesses S1.
Which section immediately follows Section 490 in Chapter XXII?
Section 491 (Prosecution to be at instance of Principal Chief Commissioner or Chief Commissioner or Principal Commissioner or Commissioner), which requires prior administrative sanction before any prosecution can be launched and empowers the compounding of any offence under Chapter XXII S2, S8.
Concise Takeaway
In summary, Section 490 of the Income-tax Act, 2025 (Presumption as to culpable mental state) provides the operative statutory rule from 1 April 2026 in Chapter XXII - Offences and Prosecutions, replacing Section 278E of the Income-tax Act, 1961 S1, S2. Readers applying Section 490 should always verify the applicable period (whether the matter pertains to Tax Year 2026-27 onwards under the 2025 Act or to a pre-1 April 2026 period governed by the 1961 Act via Section 536(2)(c)) and check all cross-referenced provisions and rules under the Income-tax Rules, 2026 S1, S3.