At-a-Glance Summary
| Attribute | Verified Legal Position |
|---|---|
| Act Name | Income-tax Act, 2025 (Act No. 30 of 2025) S2 |
| Section Number | Section 459 S1 |
| Official Heading | Penalty for failure to furnish report or for furnishing inaccurate report under section 511. S1 |
| Chapter | Chapter XXI - Penalties S1 |
| Section Category | Penalty, prosecution, or enforcement S1 |
| Legal Status | Enacted on 21 August 2025; in force from 1 April 2026 (as amended by Finance Act, 2026) S1, S2 |
| Applicable Period | Tax Year 2026-27 (beginning 1 April 2026) onwards, subject to Section 536 transition rules S2, S3 |
| 1961 Act Counterpart | Section 271GB of the Income-tax Act, 1961 S1, S2 |
Legal Function and Scope of Section 459
Section 459 of the Income-tax Act, 2025—titled "Penalty for failure to furnish report or for furnishing inaccurate report under section 511."—forms part of Chapter XXI - Penalties S1. While the Income-tax Act, 2025 received Presidential assent on 21 August 2025 as Act No. 30 of 2025, Section 1(3) postponed its general commencement to 1 April 2026 S2, section 1(3). Accordingly, Section 459 is operative law across the whole of India from 1 April 2026 (Tax Year 2026-27 onwards), replacing Section 271GB of the Income-tax Act, 1961 subject to the repeal and savings framework in Section 536 S1, S2, S3.
Provision-by-Provision Analysis of Section 459
Every sub-section, clause, and material condition enacted in Section 459 is examined below in its statutory sequence S1:
Graded Daily Penalty for Non-Filing of CbC Report (Section 459(1))
Section 459(1)(a) and (b): Provides that if any reporting entity referred to in Section 511, required to furnish the report referred to in Section 511(2) for a reporting accounting year, fails to do so, the prescribed authority under that section may impose a penalty of: (a) ₹5,000 for every day for which the failure continues, if the period of failure does not exceed one month; and (b) ₹15,000 for every day for which the failure continues beyond the period of one month. S1, S7.
Key statutory conditions, parameters, and exceptions under this provision include:
- Applies to a 'reporting entity' required to furnish the CbC Report (Form No. 59) under Section 511(2). S1, S7.
- Graded daily penalty: ₹5,000/day up to 1 month; ₹15,000/day beyond 1 month. S1, S7.
₹5,000 Daily Penalty for Non-Compliance With a Section 511(7) Verification Notice (Section 459(2))
Section 459(2): Provides that if any reporting entity referred to in Section 511 fails to produce the information and documents within the period allowed under Section 511(7), the prescribed authority may impose a penalty of ₹5,000 for every day during which the failure continues, beginning from the day immediately following the day on which the period for furnishing the information and document expires. S1.
Key statutory conditions, parameters, and exceptions under this provision include:
- Triggered when the reporting entity fails to comply with an inquiry notice under Section 511(7) within the allowed 30-day (or extended up to 60-day) window. S1.
- Rate is ₹5,000 per day starting the day after expiry of the allowed period. S1.
Escalated ₹50,000 Daily Penalty for Continuing Default After Penalty Order Service (Section 459(3))
Section 459(3): Provides that if the failure referred to in Section 459(1) or (2) continues after an order imposing a penalty under the said sub-section has been served on the entity, then, irrespective of the provisions of the said sub-sections, the prescribed authority may impose a penalty of ₹50,000 for every day for which such failure continues beginning from the date of service of such order. S1.
Key statutory conditions, parameters, and exceptions under this provision include:
- Applies to continuing recalcitrance after a penalty order under sub-section (1) or (2) has been served. S1.
- Escalates the daily penalty to ₹50,000 per day from the date of service of the initial penalty order. S1.
₹5,00,000 Penalty for Inaccurate CbC Report or Failure to Correct Within 15 Days (Section 459(4))
Section 459(4)(a), (b), and (c): Authorises the prescribed authority to impose a penalty of ₹5,00,000 on a reporting entity that provides inaccurate information in the report furnished under Section 511(2) if: (a) the entity has knowledge of the inaccuracy at the time of furnishing the report but fails to inform the prescribed authority; or (b) the entity discovers the inaccuracy after the report is furnished and fails to inform the prescribed authority and furnish a correct report within 15 days of such discovery; or (c) the entity furnishes inaccurate information or document in response to a notice issued under Section 511(7). S1.
Key statutory conditions, parameters, and exceptions under this provision include:
- Flat penalty of ₹5,00,000. S1.
- Safe harbour in clause (b): if an inadvertent inaccuracy is discovered after filing and the entity informs the authority and files a corrected report within 15 days of discovery, clause (b) is not triggered. S1.
Key Legal Terms and Definitions
To read Section 459 accurately, readers should distinguish between terms defined within Section 459 itself, terms imported from other provisions, and explanatory descriptions S1, S2:
| Term / Expression | Statutory Source Basis | Plain-Language Explanation |
|---|---|---|
| Reporting entity | Stated in Section 459 & Imported from Section 511(10)(k) | The constituent entity including the parent entity or alternate reporting entity required to furnish a Country-by-Country Report under Section 511. S1, S2 |
| Period of fifteen days of such discovery | Stated in Section 459(4)(b) | The 15-day self-correction window after discovering an inaccuracy in a filed CbC Report (distinct from the 10-day window in Sections 508(8) and 509(4)). S1, S2 |
Practical Application and Compliance Impact
Section 459 backs India's BEPS Action 13 Country-by-Country Reporting framework (Section 511) with strict, escalating monetary deterrents S1, S2. Multinational groups whose consolidated group revenue exceeds the prescribed threshold under Section 511(8) should note two critical compliance distinctions:
- 15-Day Self-Correction Window (Not 10 Days): Unlike SFTs (Section 508(8)) and Crypto statements (Section 509(4)) which allow 10 days to correct discovered inaccuracies, Section 459(4)(b) gives a reporting entity 15 days from discovery to inform the prescribed authority and furnish a corrected CbC Report (Form No. 59) to avoid the ₹5,00,000 penalty S1, section 459(4)(b).
- Reasonable Cause Under Section 470: Every sub-section of Section 459 is subject to Section 470, so if a foreign ERP consolidation delay or cross-border data restriction constitutes reasonable cause, the entity can establish that defence in response to the show-cause notice under Section 471(1) S1, S2.
Statutory Boundaries, Conditions, and Exceptions
Author analysis based on the statutory text of Section 459 and related provisions S1, S2:
- Groups Exempt Under Section 511(8): If an international group's total consolidated group revenue for the preceding accounting year is below the threshold prescribed under Section 511(8), Section 511 does not apply to the group and no penalty under Section 459 can arise S2.
- Inadvertent Error Corrected Within 15 Days: An unintentional inaccuracy in Form No. 59 that was unknown at the time of filing (clause (a)) and is duly reported and corrected within 15 days of discovery (clause (b)) does not attract the ₹5,00,000 penalty under Section 459(4) S1, section 459(4).
Related Provisions and Cross-References
Section 459 must be read harmoniously with the following provisions (with the governing Act explicitly identified for each section number) S1, S2, S3:
| Legislation | Provision Reference | Relationship to Section 459 |
|---|---|---|
| Income-tax Act, 2025 | Section 511 | Substantive Country-by-Country Reporting provision in Chapter XXIII cross-referenced throughout Section 459. S1, S2 |
| Income-tax Rules, 2026 | Forms No. 58, 59, and 60 | Prescribed forms for CbCR intimations and reports under Section 511. S7 |
| Income-tax Act, 2025 | Section 470 | Provides the reasonable-cause defence applicable to Section 459. S2 |
| Income-tax Act, 1961 | Section 271GB | Corresponding provision in the repealed 1961 Act. S1, S2 |
Transition and Comparison with the Income-tax Act, 1961
Section 459 corresponds word-for-word in substance to Section 271GB of the repealed Income-tax Act, 1961, updating the statutory cross-references from old Section 286 to Section 511 of the Income-tax Act, 2025 S1, S2.
Distinction Between 'Tax Year', 'Previous Year', and 'Assessment Year': Under the repealed Income-tax Act, 1961, income earned in a 'previous year' (financial year) was taxed in the following 'assessment year'. Under Section 3 of the Income-tax Act, 2025, that dual terminology is replaced from 1 April 2026 by a single 'tax year' (the 12-month period beginning on 1st April) S2, section 3. Under Section 536(3) of the 2025 Act, any reference to a tax year commencing on or before 1 April 2025 is construed as a reference to the corresponding 'previous year' under the repealed 1961 Act S3, section 536(3).
Hypothetical Illustrations
The following examples are hypothetical scenarios designed to illustrate the operation of Section 459 S1:
Illustration EX1: Graded Daily Penalty Calculation for 45-Day Delay in Filing Form No. 59 (Hypothetical)
- Facts: An Indian ultimate parent company (a reporting entity under Section 511(2)) is required to file its Country-by-Country Report in Form No. 59 for Reporting Accounting Year 2026-27 on or before 31 March 2028. It files the report after a delay of 45 days (where the first month of April has 30 days, plus 15 days in May) without proving reasonable cause under Section 470.
- Assumptions: The first month of default consists of 30 days, and the period beyond one month is 15 days (total 45 days). No reasonable cause under Section 470 is established.
- Legal Question: How is the penalty computed under Section 459(1)(a) and (b)?
- Analysis: Under Section 459(1)(a), the penalty is ₹5,000 per day for the period not exceeding one month (30 days × ₹5,000 = ₹1,50,000) S1, section 459(1)(a). Under Section 459(1)(b), the penalty is ₹15,000 per day for the period continuing beyond one month (15 days × ₹15,000 = ₹2,25,000) S1, section 459(1)(b). Total penalty = ₹1,50,000 + ₹2,25,000 = ₹3,75,000.
- Conclusion: The prescribed authority may impose a total penalty of ₹3,75,000 under Section 459(1).
Illustration EX2: Prompt Correction of Discovered CbCR Inaccuracy Within 15 Days (Hypothetical)
- Facts: After filing Form No. 59 on time without knowledge of any error, a reporting entity discovers on 10 May 2028 that the employee headcount of its German subsidiary was misstated due to a currency-to-headcount column shift. On 20 May 2028 (within 10 days of discovery), the entity informs the prescribed authority and files a revised, accurate Form No. 59.
- Assumptions: The entity had no knowledge of the inaccuracy at the time of original filing, and informed the authority and furnished the correct report within 15 days of discovery.
- Legal Question: Is the entity liable to the ₹5,00,000 penalty under Section 459(4)?
- Analysis: Under Section 459(4)(a) and (b), the ₹5,00,000 penalty applies only if the entity knew of the inaccuracy at the time of filing and failed to inform the authority, or discovered the inaccuracy after filing and failed to inform the authority and furnish a correct report within 15 days of discovery S1, section 459(4)(a)-(b). Since the entity corrected the report within 10 days (well within the 15-day window), neither clause is triggered.
- Conclusion: No. Because the entity informed the authority and furnished the corrected report within 15 days of discovery, no penalty is leviable under Section 459(4).
Common Misconceptions and Legal Corrections
-
Misconception 1: "The daily penalty for late filing of a Country-by-Country Report under Section 459(1) is capped at ₹1,00,000 like SFT penalties under Section 454."
- Legal Correction: Unlike Section 454, Section 459(1)–(3) contains no ₹1,00,000 ceiling; instead, the daily penalty escalates from ₹5,000/day (first month) to ₹15,000/day (beyond one month) and ₹50,000/day (after service of a penalty order) S1.
-
Misconception 2: "Any error in a CbC Report automatically triggers a ₹5,00,000 penalty even if corrected immediately upon discovery."
- Legal Correction: Under Section 459(4)(b), if an inadvertent error discovered after filing is reported and corrected within 15 days of discovery, the ₹5,00,000 penalty does not apply S1, section 459(4)(b).
Reader Questions (FAQs)
What are the three daily penalty rates under Section 459(1), (2), and (3)?
Under Section 459(1), late filing of the CbC report attracts ₹5,000/day for the first month and ₹15,000/day beyond one month. Under Section 459(2), non-production of documents under Section 511(7) attracts ₹5,000/day. Under Section 459(3), continuing failure after service of a penalty order under sub-section (1) or (2) attracts ₹50,000/day S1.
How many days does a reporting entity have after discovering an error in its CbC report to file a corrected report without penalty under Section 459(4)(b)?
Under Section 459(4)(b), the reporting entity has 15 days from the discovery of the inaccuracy to inform the prescribed authority and furnish the correct report S1, section 459(4)(b).
Does Section 470 (reasonable cause) apply to penalties under Section 459?
Yes. Section 470 explicitly lists Section 459, so no penalty shall be imposed if the reporting entity proves reasonable cause for the failure S2.
Concise Takeaway
In summary, Section 459 of the Income-tax Act, 2025 (Penalty for failure to furnish report or for furnishing inaccurate report under section 511) provides the operative statutory rule from 1 April 2026 in Chapter XXI - Penalties, replacing Section 271GB of the Income-tax Act, 1961 S1, S2. Readers applying Section 459 should always verify the applicable period (whether the matter pertains to Tax Year 2026-27 onwards under the 2025 Act or to a pre-1 April 2026 period governed by the 1961 Act via Section 536(2)(c)) and check all cross-referenced provisions and rules under the Income-tax Rules, 2026 S1, S3.