At-a-Glance Summary
| Attribute | Verified Legal Position |
|---|---|
| Act Name | Income-tax Act, 2025 (Act No. 30 of 2025) S2 |
| Section Number | Section 458 S1 |
| Official Heading | Penalty for failure to furnish information or document under section 506. S1 |
| Chapter | Chapter XXI - Penalties S1 |
| Section Category | Penalty, prosecution, or enforcement S1 |
| Legal Status | Enacted on 21 August 2025; in force from 1 April 2026 (as amended by Finance Act, 2026) S1, S2 |
| Applicable Period | Tax Year 2026-27 (beginning 1 April 2026) onwards, subject to Section 536 transition rules S2, S3 |
| 1961 Act Counterpart | Section 271GA of the Income-tax Act, 1961 S1, S2 |
Legal Function and Scope of Section 458
Section 458 of the Income-tax Act, 2025—titled "Penalty for failure to furnish information or document under section 506."—forms part of Chapter XXI - Penalties S1. While the Income-tax Act, 2025 received Presidential assent on 21 August 2025 as Act No. 30 of 2025, Section 1(3) postponed its general commencement to 1 April 2026 S2, section 1(3). Accordingly, Section 458 is operative law across the whole of India from 1 April 2026 (Tax Year 2026-27 onwards), replacing Section 271GA of the Income-tax Act, 1961 subject to the repeal and savings framework in Section 536 S1, S2, S3.
Provision-by-Provision Analysis of Section 458
Every sub-section, clause, and material condition enacted in Section 458 is examined below in its statutory sequence S1:
Two-Tier Penalty Structure: 2% of Transaction Value vs. ₹5,00,000 (Section 458(a)–(b))
Section 458(a) and (b): Provides that if any Indian concern, which is required to furnish any information or document under Section 506, fails to do so, the prescribed income-tax authority under that section may direct that such Indian concern shall pay, by way of penalty, a sum of: (a) 2% of the value of the transaction in respect of which such failure has taken place, if such transaction had the effect of directly or indirectly transferring the right of management or control in relation to the Indian concern; or (b) ₹5,00,000, in any other case. S1, S2.
Key statutory conditions, parameters, and exceptions under this provision include:
- Applies specifically to an 'Indian concern' obligated to report under Section 506. S1, S2.
- Tier 1 (Clause (a)): 2% of transaction value where right of management or control in relation to the Indian concern is directly or indirectly transferred. S1, S2.
- Tier 2 (Clause (b)): Flat ₹5,00,000 where management or control is not transferred. S1, S2.
- Subject to the reasonable-cause defence under Section 470. S1, S2.
Key Legal Terms and Definitions
To read Section 458 accurately, readers should distinguish between terms defined within Section 458 itself, terms imported from other provisions, and explanatory descriptions S1, S2:
| Term / Expression | Statutory Source Basis | Plain-Language Explanation |
|---|---|---|
| Indian concern | Stated in Section 458 & Imported from Section 506 | The domestic Indian company or entity through or in which the foreign company/entity holds assets located in India as referred to in Section 9(10)(a) and Section 506. S1, S2 |
| Transferring the right of management or control | Stated in Section 458(a) | Any offshore share or interest transfer that results in a direct or indirect change in the right to control the board or management of the Indian concern. S1, S2 |
Practical Application and Compliance Impact
Section 458 calibrates the penalty on the Indian concern based on the materiality of the offshore indirect transfer S1:
- If a foreign parent transfers a controlling stake (e.g., 60% or 100% of the offshore holding company's shares) so that management or control of the Indian concern changes hands, the Indian concern will invariably know about the change in its ultimate board control; failing to report that transaction in Form No. 163 under Section 506 attracts a heavy 2% penalty on the transaction value under Section 458(a) S1, section 458(a).
- If, however, a minority non-controlling stake (e.g., 8% of the offshore holding company) is transferred without shifting management or control of the Indian concern, the penalty under Section 458(b) is capped at a flat ₹5,00,000 (and if the Indian concern had no knowledge and could not reasonably know of an offshore minority trade, it can invoke Section 470 reasonable cause) S1, S2.
Statutory Boundaries, Conditions, and Exceptions
Author analysis based on the statutory text of Section 458 and related provisions S1, S2:
- Prerequisite of Section 506 Applicability: If the offshore shares/interests do not derive their value substantially from assets located in India under Section 9(10)(a), Section 506 does not apply, and consequently no penalty can be levied under Section 458 S1, S2.
- Reasonable Cause Under Section 470: Section 470 expressly includes Section 458 S2.
Related Provisions and Cross-References
Section 458 must be read harmoniously with the following provisions (with the governing Act explicitly identified for each section number) S1, S2, S3:
| Legislation | Provision Reference | Relationship to Section 458 |
|---|---|---|
| Income-tax Act, 2025 | Section 506 and Section 9(10)(a) | Impose the domestic reporting duty on the Indian concern and define substantial-value indirect transfers. S1, S2 |
| Income-tax Rules, 2026 | Rule 235 and Form No. 163 | Prescribe the manner, timeline, and form for compliance under Section 506. S6, S7 |
| Income-tax Act, 2025 | Section 470 | Provides the reasonable-cause defence applicable to Section 458. S2 |
| Income-tax Act, 1961 | Section 271GA | Corresponding provision in the repealed 1961 Act. S1, S2 |
Transition and Comparison with the Income-tax Act, 1961
Section 458 corresponds word-for-word in substance to Section 271GA of the repealed Income-tax Act, 1961, updating the cross-reference from old Section 285A to Section 506 of the Income-tax Act, 2025 S1, S2.
Distinction Between 'Tax Year', 'Previous Year', and 'Assessment Year': Under the repealed Income-tax Act, 1961, income earned in a 'previous year' (financial year) was taxed in the following 'assessment year'. Under Section 3 of the Income-tax Act, 2025, that dual terminology is replaced from 1 April 2026 by a single 'tax year' (the 12-month period beginning on 1st April) S2, section 3. Under Section 536(3) of the 2025 Act, any reference to a tax year commencing on or before 1 April 2025 is construed as a reference to the corresponding 'previous year' under the repealed 1961 Act S3, section 536(3).
Hypothetical Illustrations
The following examples are hypothetical scenarios designed to illustrate the operation of Section 458 S1:
Illustration EX1: Offshore Acquisition Transferring Control of Indian Subsidiary (2% Penalty Under Clause (a)) (Hypothetical)
- Facts: Mauritius HoldCo transfers 100% of the shares of Singapore IntermediateCo (whose value is derived 95% from its wholly owned Indian subsidiary, Pune Infra Pvt. Ltd.) for ₹200 crore in August 2026. The transaction indirectly transfers the right of management and control over Pune Infra Pvt. Ltd. to the new acquirer. Pune Infra Pvt. Ltd. fails to furnish Form No. 163 under Section 506 within the prescribed period without reasonable cause.
- Assumptions: Pune Infra Pvt. Ltd. is an Indian concern required to furnish information/documents under Section 506. The ₹200 crore transaction had the effect of indirectly transferring the right of management and control in relation to Pune Infra Pvt. Ltd., and no reasonable cause under Section 470 exists.
- Legal Question: What is the penalty imposable on Pune Infra Pvt. Ltd. under Section 458?
- Analysis: Under Section 458(a) of the Income-tax Act, 2025, where the offshore transaction had the effect of directly or indirectly transferring the right of management or control in relation to the Indian concern, the penalty is 2% of the value of the transaction S1, section 458(a). Computing 2% of ₹200,00,00,000 equals ₹4,00,00,000 (₹4 crore).
- Conclusion: The prescribed income-tax authority may direct Pune Infra Pvt. Ltd. to pay a penalty of ₹4,00,00,000 (₹4 crore) under Section 458(a).
Illustration EX2: Offshore Minority Stake Transfer Not Affecting Management or Control (₹5,00,000 Under Clause (b)) (Hypothetical)
- Facts: Assume the same structure as Example 1, except that an offshore investor transfers only a 7% non-controlling stake in Singapore IntermediateCo for ₹14 crore without any right to appoint directors or affect management or control of Pune Infra Pvt. Ltd. Pune Infra Pvt. Ltd. fails to file Form No. 163 under Section 506 without reasonable cause.
- Assumptions: The transaction did NOT have the effect of directly or indirectly transferring the right of management or control in relation to Pune Infra Pvt. Ltd.
- Legal Question: What penalty applies under Section 458—2% of ₹14 crore (₹28 lakh) or ₹5,00,000?
- Analysis: Because the transaction did not transfer the right of management or control in relation to the Indian concern, Section 458(a) does not apply; instead, the case falls under Section 458(b) ('Rs. 500000, in any other case') S1, section 458(b).
- Conclusion: Under Section 458(b), the penalty is a fixed sum of ₹5,00,000.
Common Misconceptions and Legal Corrections
-
Misconception 1: "Every default under Section 506 attracts a 2% penalty on the offshore transaction value."
- Legal Correction: Under Section 458(a) and (b), the 2% penalty applies only if the transaction had the effect of directly or indirectly transferring the right of management or control in relation to the Indian concern; in all other cases, the penalty is a flat ₹5,00,000 S1.
-
Misconception 2: "The penalty under Section 458 is levied on the foreign seller of the offshore shares."
- Legal Correction: Section 458 directs that the Indian concern shall pay the penalty for failing to comply with its domestic reporting duty under Section 506 S1.
Reader Questions (FAQs)
When does the 2% penalty under Section 458(a) apply instead of the ₹5,00,000 penalty under Section 458(b)?
The 2% penalty under Section 458(a) applies only when the transaction in respect of which the failure took place had the effect of directly or indirectly transferring the right of management or control in relation to the Indian concern; in all other cases, the flat ₹5,00,000 penalty under Section 458(b) applies S1.
Which form must an Indian concern file under Section 506 to avoid penalty under Section 458?
Under Rule 235 of the Income-tax Rules, 2026, the Indian concern must furnish the required information and documents in Form No. 163 (which replaced Form No. 49D of the 1962 Rules) S6, S7.
Can an Indian concern plead reasonable cause under Section 470 against a Section 458 penalty?
Yes. Section 470 expressly includes Section 458, barring imposition of penalty if the Indian concern proves reasonable cause for the failure S2.
Concise Takeaway
In summary, Section 458 of the Income-tax Act, 2025 (Penalty for failure to furnish information or document under section 506) provides the operative statutory rule from 1 April 2026 in Chapter XXI - Penalties, replacing Section 271GA of the Income-tax Act, 1961 S1, S2. Readers applying Section 458 should always verify the applicable period (whether the matter pertains to Tax Year 2026-27 onwards under the 2025 Act or to a pre-1 April 2026 period governed by the 1961 Act via Section 536(2)(c)) and check all cross-referenced provisions and rules under the Income-tax Rules, 2026 S1, S3.