At a glance
| Item | Position |
|---|---|
| Act and provision | Income-tax Act, 2025, section 450 |
| Official heading | Penalty for failure to comply with provisions of section 185. |
| Location | Chapter XXI: Penalties |
| General commencement | 1 April 2026 |
| Research date | 16 October 2026 |
| Legal status | Enacted and operative |
| Legal function | Penalty for prohibited receipt of loans, deposits or property sums |
The section operates within the Act’s charging and computation framework. The period and applicable version must be identified before applying it. S1, sections 1(3), 3, 4 and 450
The contravention is taking or accepting the amount
The penalty applies to the person taking/accepting a loan, deposit or specified sum contrary to section 185. It is not the repayment penalty under section 453 and not the separate general-receipt restriction under section 186. Identify the receipt and its legal character before selecting the penalty section. S1, Section 450, trigger
The amount is the contravening receipt, not just the threshold excess
The AO may impose a penalty equal to the amount so taken or accepted. The threshold is a condition identifying restricted receipts; the section does not say to penalise only the portion above ₹20,000. Nor does it automatically make the entire historically outstanding loan the new penalty base merely because that balance triggers aggregation. S1, Section 450, amount and authority
The ordinary threshold includes existing unpaid amounts
Section 185 applies at ₹20,000 or more if the current receipt/aggregate, the previously accepted unpaid amount from the same person, or their aggregate meets the test. A previous balance counts whether repayment is due or not. Splitting a new receipt into smaller amounts does not automatically avoid the aggregation rule. Loan/deposit means money; specified sum under section 189(c) includes money receivable as an advance or otherwise for transfer of immovable property, whether or not the transfer occurs. S1, sections 185(1), (5) and 189(c)
Use a permitted mode
Section 185 permits account-payee cheque, account-payee bank draft, electronic clearing through a bank account or prescribed electronic modes. Rule 48 lists credit/debit cards, net banking, IMPS, UPI, RTGS, NEFT, BHIM Aadhaar Pay and the specified full-KYC Tier-III CBDC/P-CBDC/wholesale or cross-border CBDC modes. A bearer cheque or an untraceable cash handover is not made compliant merely by calling it a banking transaction. S1, section 185(1)(a)–(d); S2, rule 48
Exceptions and the limited agricultural co-operative threshold
Section 185(2) excludes the described receipts from or by Government, banks/post office savings banks/co-operative banks, statutory corporations, Government companies and notified institutions/classes. Subsection (3) requires both parties to have agricultural income and neither to have taxable income. Subsection (4) substitutes ₹2 lakh for the specified member-deposit/member-loan relationships with the named agricultural credit societies/banks; it is not a ₹2 lakh limit for every co-operative transaction or every property advance. The statutory definition cross-reference in section 189(b) must also be checked. S1, sections 185(2)–(4) and 189(b)
Hearing, approval and limitation remain relevant
Section 471 requires a hearing or reasonable opportunity through a show-cause notice. Prior Joint Commissioner approval is required for an Income-tax Officer’s penalty above ₹10,000 or an Assistant/Deputy Commissioner’s penalty above ₹20,000. Section 472 supplies limitation rules, including the relevant quarter-based trigger and specified exclusions; do not assume every case runs from the transaction date. These safeguards do not themselves establish the substantive default. S1, sections 471(1)–(3) and 472
Reasonable cause is an express protection
Section 470 includes this penalty provision and bars penalty for the covered failure if the person proves reasonable cause. Preserve evidence of the cause, its connection to the failure and corrective action. It is a statutory defence to be established, not an automatic exemption obtained by paying the underlying tax late. S1, section 470
Hypothetical illustrations
A small new receipt on an existing balance
Facts: For tax year 2026–27, ₹15,000 of an earlier loan from the same person remains unpaid, and another ₹10,000 is accepted in cash with no applicable exception.
Assumptions: The stated facts are hypothetical and supported by records. Any rates illustrated are base income-tax rates; surcharge, cess, interest and penalties are excluded unless expressly calculated. Amounts are exact at the precision shown; no additional rounding adjustment is illustrated unless expressly stated.
Question: Does being below ₹20,000 for the new payment alone avoid the restriction?
Analysis: No. The combined ₹25,000 meets the aggregation test. The identified new contravening receipt is ₹10,000; section 450’s penalty for that receipt, if lawfully imposed, equals ₹10,000 rather than only the ₹5,000 threshold excess. This example does not assume the earlier receipt was itself unlawful.
Conclusion: Distinguish the aggregation trigger from the receipt being penalised. S1
Reader questions
Does proving a loan is genuine automatically satisfy the permitted-mode requirement?
No. Genuineness and payment mode are different issues. Any reasonable-cause defence must be proved under section 470. S1