At a glance
| Item | Position |
|---|---|
| Act and provision | Income-tax Act, 2025, section 445 |
| Official heading | Benefits to related persons. |
| Location | Chapter XXI: Penalties |
| General commencement | 1 April 2026 |
| Research date | 16 October 2026 |
| Legal status | Enacted and operative |
| Legal function | Penalty for registered non-profit income benefiting related persons |
The section operates within the Act’s charging and computation framework. The period and applicable version must be identified before applying it. S1, sections 1(3), 3, 4 and 445
The organisation and income must satisfy the gateway
During proceedings, a registered non-profit organisation must be found to have specified income chargeable under section 337 Table row 2. The AO may impose the penalty on the organisation. This is not a penalty automatically charged to every employee, donor or trustee receiving any payment. S1, Section 445, gateway and authority
First-noticed and subsequent-year violations differ
For a violation noticed for the first time during any tax year, penalty equals the aggregate income applied directly or indirectly for the benefit of section 355(h) related persons. If the violation is noticed again in a subsequent tax year, the figure is 200% of that aggregate. The wording is about first notice and a subsequent-year repeat, not an automatic 200% on the second invoice in the same year. S1, Section 445(a), Section 445(b)
Related person is a defined category
Section 355(h) includes author/founder; a contributor above ₹1 lakh in the relevant tax year or ₹10 lakh cumulatively; the relevant HUF member; trustee/manager; the specifically referenced relatives; and concerns in which the identified persons have substantial interest. The relative/concern extensions refer to the named sub-clauses, not indiscriminately to every contributor’s entire family. Section 355(i)/(n) defines relative and substantial interest. S1, section 355(h)–(i), (n)
Rule 183 identifies benefit situations
The rule covers lending without adequate security or interest, property use without adequate rent/compensation, excessive remuneration for services, services/goods without adequate consideration, buying property too dearly from or selling too cheaply to a related person, the specified income/property diversion above ₹1,000, and funds invested in a substantially interested concern for the stated period. Sub-rule (2) measures the benefit/facility provided free or concessionally. It is therefore unsafe to equate every reasonable salary paid to a trustee with the entire prohibited benefit without checking value and conditions. S2, rule 183
Hearing, approval and limitation remain relevant
Section 471 requires a hearing or reasonable opportunity through a show-cause notice. Prior Joint Commissioner approval is required for an Income-tax Officer’s penalty above ₹10,000 or an Assistant/Deputy Commissioner’s penalty above ₹20,000. Section 472 supplies limitation rules, including the relevant quarter-based trigger and specified exclusions; do not assume every case runs from the transaction date. These safeguards do not themselves establish the substantive default. S1, sections 471(1)–(3) and 472
Tax, penalty and other non-profit consequences are separate
The benefit first needs the section 337 classification and prescribed computation. Section 445 then applies its penalty percentage. Section 470 does not list section 445, so do not promise its specific reasonable-cause immunity here. Any registration or exemption consequence requires analysis under its own provision and is not decided simply by multiplying this penalty. S1, sections 337, 445 and 470
Hypothetical illustrations
A benefit-value comparison
Facts: For tax year 2026–27, a properly computed related-person benefit is ₹40,000.
Assumptions: The stated facts are hypothetical and supported by records. Any rates illustrated are base income-tax rates; surcharge, cess, interest and penalties are excluded unless expressly calculated. Amounts are exact at the precision shown; no additional rounding adjustment is illustrated unless expressly stated.
Question: How do the two penalty branches differ?
Analysis: A first-noticed qualifying violation uses ₹40,000; a qualifying repeat noticed in a subsequent tax year uses ₹80,000. These are alternatives depending on the history, not two amounts to add for the same branch.
Conclusion: Establish both benefit value and violation history. S1
Reader questions
Does paying a related person a reasonable market salary automatically establish this penalty?
No. The section 337/Rule 183 benefit conditions and actual excess or concession must be established. S1, S2