At a glance
| Item | Position |
|---|---|
| Act and provision | Income-tax Act, 2025, section 436 |
| Official heading | Correctness of assessment not to be questioned. |
| Location | Chapter XX: Refunds |
| General commencement | 1 April 2026 |
| Research date | 16 October 2026 |
| Legal status | Enacted and operative |
| Legal function | A refund claim cannot reopen a final assessment |
The section operates within the Act’s charging and computation framework. The period and applicable version must be identified before applying it. S1, sections 1(3), 3, 4 and 436
Final assessments and decided matters cannot be reargued here
Within a claim under this Chapter, the assessee cannot question the correctness of a final and conclusive assessment or other decided matter, or ask for its review. A refund request does not itself revive an expired challenge route or give the refund officer an unrestricted appellate power. S1, Section 436, finality and review bar
The permissible relief remains an actual refund
The section confines relief on the claim to tax wrongly paid or paid in excess. Establish the overpayment within the legally operative liability position. If the true complaint is that the assessment should have allowed a deduction, the appropriate appeal, rectification or revision route must be considered under its own eligibility and limitation rules. S1, Section 436, permitted relief
Distinguish a payment error from an assessment challenge
A duplicated tax payment can be different from disputing a deduction already conclusively rejected. The former calls for reconciling payments against liability; the latter seeks a change to the liability decision. Sections 287, 356–357 and 377–378 provide particular correction/challenge mechanisms, but this section does not guarantee that any of them remains available in a given case. S1, sections 287, 356–357, 377–378 and 431–436
Hypothetical illustrations
A final deduction dispute
Facts: For tax year 2026–27, a deduction was disallowed by an assessment that has become final and conclusive, and the assessee now asks for a refund solely by recalculating that deduction as allowed.
Assumptions: The stated facts are hypothetical and supported by records. Any rates illustrated are base income-tax rates; surcharge, cess, interest and penalties are excluded unless expressly calculated.
Question: Can the refund claim itself review that decision?
Analysis: No. Section 436 bars that use of the refund route. A separately available lawful remedy would need its own basis and time-limit analysis.
Conclusion: Identify whether the claim concerns excess payment or a change in assessed liability. S1
Reader questions
Does section 436 say genuine overpayments can never be refunded?
No. It preserves refund of tax wrongly paid or paid in excess while preventing the specified collateral challenge to final decisions. S1