At a glance
| Item | Position |
|---|---|
| Act and provision | Income-tax Act, 2025, section 435 |
| Official heading | Refund on appeal, etc. |
| Location | Chapter XX: Refunds |
| General commencement | 1 April 2026 |
| Research date | 16 October 2026 |
| Legal status | Enacted and operative |
| Legal function | Consequential refunds and the effect of different appellate outcomes |
The section operates within the Act’s charging and computation framework. The period and applicable version must be identified before applying it. S1, sections 1(3), 3, 4 and 435
An order-generated refund ordinarily needs no fresh claim
Where an appeal or other proceeding under the Act produces a refund due to the assessee, the AO must refund it without the assessee making a separate claim, except as otherwise provided in the Act. This does not erase lawful set-off/withholding or establish that every favourable order produces a positive refund. S1, Section 435(1)
A fresh-assessment direction postpones the refund determination
Where an assessment is set aside or cancelled and a fresh assessment is directed, the refund, if any, becomes due only when that fresh assessment is made. Cancelling the earlier order in that setting is not the same as immediately refunding every payment. Read the operative directions, not merely the headline result. S1, Section 435(2)(a)
Annulment retains the tax on returned income
Where the assessment is annulled, refund is due only for tax paid in excess of tax chargeable on the total income returned. It does not automatically refund the amount properly chargeable on the taxpayer’s own return. The returned-income comparator is specific to this clause. S1, Section 435(2)(b)
Order effect, interest and adjustment require reconciliation
Keep the appellate order, effect-giving computation, payments and existing demands together. Section 437 governs ordinary and specified additional refund interest; section 438 addresses written-intimation set-off and reasoned withholding. Those provisions operate alongside the no-separate-claim rule, rather than converting it into an unconditional cash-payment promise. S1, sections 437–438
Hypothetical illustrations
Annulment is not a refund of all tax
Facts: For tax year 2026–27, tax paid is ₹1,20,000, tax correctly chargeable on returned income is ₹80,000, and the assessment is annulled.
Assumptions: The stated facts are hypothetical and supported by records. Any rates illustrated are base income-tax rates; surcharge, cess, interest and penalties are excluded unless expressly calculated. Amounts are exact at the precision shown; no additional rounding adjustment is illustrated unless expressly stated.
Question: What excess is identified by subsection (2)(b)?
Analysis: ₹40,000, not ₹1,20,000, assuming the figures and annulment classification are correct. Interest and adjustment require separate examination.
Conclusion: Use the returned-income tax comparator. S1
Reader questions
Is a direction for fresh assessment treated exactly like annulment?
No. Subsection (2)(a) waits for the fresh assessment; subsection (2)(b) uses tax on returned income after annulment. S1