At a glance
| Item | Position |
|---|---|
| Act and provision | Income-tax Act, 2025, section 38 |
| Official heading | Certain sums deemed as profits and gains of business or profession. |
| Location | Chapter IV, Part D: Profits and gains of business or profession |
| Legal status | Enacted and operative; editorial draft |
| General commencement | 1 April 2026 |
| Legal function | Taxation of recoveries, reversals and specified asset realisations |
Trading liabilities, losses and expenses
Clause (1)(a) covers an earlier allowed loss, expenditure or trading liability. A later benefit from cessation or remission of the liability, including a unilateral book write-off, is taxed in the benefit year. A later cash or non-cash amount obtained in respect of the earlier loss or expense is taxed in the receipt year. Subsection (2)(a) requires the earlier allowance or deduction to have been made in assessment. Continuing existence of the original business is not required. S1, section 38(1)(a)(i)–(ii), (2)(a)
Do not assume that every old unpaid creditor has legally ceased to exist just because time has passed. Establish the statutory event and earlier allowance. Conversely, the express unilateral-write-off wording means a taxpayer cannot ignore its own qualifying liability write-back. S1, section 38(1)(a)
Power-method tangible assets: the balancing amount
Clause (1)(b), with subsection (2)(b), concerns an owned tangible business/professional asset on which depreciation was claimed and allowed under section 33(2). On sale, discard, demolition or destruction, compare money payable plus scrap value (A), actual cost (B) and written-down value (C). If A exceeds C but is below B, the business-income amount is A − C; otherwise it is B − C. The year is when the money becomes due. This does not substitute an individual-asset balancing charge for every ordinary block-method disposal. S1, section 38(1)(b)(i)–(ii), (2)(b)
Research assets, bad debts and reserve withdrawals
Clause (1)(c) covers sale of an asset representing scientific-research capital expenditure under section 45(1)(a)(i), without intervening use for other purposes. Where sale proceeds plus total deductions exceed capital expenditure, tax the excess or the deductions, whichever is lower, in the sale year. Subsection (2)(c) repeats the no-other-use condition. S1, section 38(1)(c), (2)(c)
Clause (1)(d) taxes a bad-debt recovery after a section 31(2) deduction only to the extent it exceeds the debt minus the amount previously allowed. The entire recovery is not always income; first identify the undeducted portion. Clause (1)(e) taxes an amount withdrawn from a special reserve for which deduction was allowed under section 32(e), in the withdrawal year. S1, section 38(1)(d)–(e)
Closed businesses and successors
Subsection (3) provides a specific set-off after cessation: a non-speculation loss from the cessation year, unabsorbed against that year’s other income, may so far as possible be set off against later income under clauses (1)(a), (c), (d) or (e) relating to that business. Clause (1)(b) is not on this list. This is not permission to bring every old loss into the recovery year. S1, section 38(3)
Subsection (4) charges a successor where the clause (1)(a) benefit accrues to it or the amount is obtained by it. Subsection (5) expressly applies clauses (1)(b)–(e) even where the business no longer exists; clause (1)(a) already contains that rule. S1, section 38(4)–(5)
The section’s definitions
“Sold” includes exchange and compulsory acquisition, but excludes the specified amalgamation transfer to an Indian amalgamated company. “Successor in business” includes the amalgamated company, the resulting company on demerger, another person succeeding to the business/profession, and a succeeding firm where one firm succeeds another. The identity of the recipient and the transaction therefore matter alongside the amount recovered. S1, section 38(6)(a)–(b)
Hypothetical illustrations
Recovery after only a partial bad-debt deduction
Facts: A ₹1,00,000 debt had a ₹60,000 deduction allowed under section 31(2). ₹70,000 is later recovered in tax year 2026–27.
Assumptions: The earlier deduction and recovery are established.
Question: Is all ₹70,000 taxed under clause (d)?
Analysis: The undeducted part is ₹1,00,000 − ₹60,000 = ₹40,000. Recovery exceeds it by ₹30,000.
Conclusion: ₹30,000 is the section 38(1)(d) income component. S1
Balancing amount capped at earlier depreciation
Facts: A qualifying section 33(2) asset has actual cost ₹10,00,000, written-down value ₹6,00,000 and money payable plus scrap of ₹12,00,000 becoming due in tax year 2026–27.
Assumptions: Subsections (1)(b) and (2)(b) apply. Only this business-income charge is calculated; any separate capital-gains question is outside the illustration.
Question: What amount does clause (b) charge?
Analysis: Since proceeds are at least actual cost, use ₹10,00,000 − ₹6,00,000 = ₹4,00,000, not ₹12,00,000 − ₹6,00,000.
Conclusion: The clause (b) business-income amount is ₹4,00,000. S1
Trading liability written back
Facts: A trading expense was allowed in assessment. In tax year 2026–27 the assessee unilaterally writes off the corresponding ₹50,000 payable in its accounts.
Assumptions: The write-off constitutes the event described in clause (1)(a)(i); no amount is being counted twice.
Question: Does absence of a cash receipt prevent the charge?
Analysis: No. Clause (1)(a)(i) expressly includes the specified unilateral liability write-off.
Conclusion: The ₹50,000 benefit is chargeable in the write-off tax year on these facts. S1
Reader questions
Does closing the business prevent later recovery taxation?
No. The section expressly preserves the relevant charges, with a limited cessation-year loss set-off under subsection (3). S1
Is an accounting reserve release always taxable under the reserve clause?
Clause (1)(e) specifically concerns withdrawal from a reserve whose deduction was allowed under section 32(e). Identify that statutory reserve and earlier allowance rather than treating every reserve alike. S1