At a glance
| Item | Position |
|---|---|
| Act and provision | Income-tax Act, 2025, section 357 |
| Official heading | Appealable orders before Commissioner (Appeals). |
| Location | Chapter XVIII: Appeals, revisions and alternate dispute resolutions; Part A: Appeals; 1: Appeals to Joint Commissioner (Appeals) and Commissioner (Appeals) |
| General commencement | 1 April 2026 |
| Research date | 15 October 2026 |
| Legal status | Enacted and operative |
| Legal function | Orders eligible for Commissioner (Appeals) review |
The section operates within the Act’s charging and computation framework. The period and applicable version must be identified before applying it. S1, sections 1(3), 3, 4 and 357
Joint Commissioner’s section 231(4)(b) order
This is the specifically named tonnage-tax order; use the provision in the order rather than a general company-tax label. S1, Section 357(a)
Denial of liability to be assessed
The category covers an order against an assessee who denies liability to be assessed under the Act; this is not merely a statement that a calculation seems high. S1, Section 357(b)
Processing adjustments
An intimation under section 270(1) or 399(1) is covered where the assessee, deductor or collector objects to adjustments. S1, Section 357(c)
Assessment objections
The clause addresses assessment under section 270(10) or 271 and objections to assessed income, determined tax, computed loss or status. Preserve the stated exclusions for DRP-direction and section 274(12) orders; section 362 provides their direct Tribunal routes. S1, Section 357(d)
Reassessment and related orders
Section 279 assessment/reassessment/recomputation is covered except the stated DRP-direction or section 274(12) orders; the clause also names section 283. S1, Section 357(e)
Modified-return assessment
The specifically identified order is section 169(3)(a). S1, Section 357(f)
Adverse rectification or amendment decisions
Section 287 or 288 orders enhancing assessment, reducing refund or refusing the assessee’s claim are covered, except the stated section 274(12) order. Not every clerical change is automatically the described adverse order. S1, Section 357(g)
Non-resident agent treatment
A section 306 order treating the assessee as agent of a non-resident is covered. S1, Section 357(h)
Business succession liability
The specific orders are section 313(2) or (4). S1, Section 357(i)
HUF order
The clause names an order under section 315. S1, Section 357(j)
Deduction/collection-related order
The clause names section 398. S1, Section 357(k)
Refund entitlement
A section 431 order concerning entitlement to refund of tax paid above the amount properly chargeable is covered. S1, Section 357(l)
Refund where the payer denies a deduction obligation
Section 434 concerns the specified written-arrangement case where the payer bears and pays the tax but claims no deduction was required; the AO’s order on that refund application is covered. S1, Section 357(m)
Chapter XXI penalty
An order imposing or enhancing a penalty under Chapter XXI is covered. S1, Section 357(n)
Section 412 penalty
This is the separately listed penalty under section 412. S1, Section 357(o)
Block-assessment order
An order under section 294(1)(c) is expressly included. S1, Section 357(p)
Section 298(2) penalty
The block-related penalty provision is specifically listed. S1, Section 357(q)
Additional Board-directed classes
An AO order for a person or class may qualify where the Board directs, having regard to the nature, complexity and other relevant considerations. This is not an unrestricted taxpayer choice to add any unlisted order. S1, Section 357(r)
The list must be read with forum allocation
Section 356 supplies the Joint Commissioner (Appeals) route, its rank/approval restriction, transfers and Board powers. Section 362 supplies direct ITAT routes for specified DRP, section 274(12), senior-authority and other orders. Do not file duplicate first appeals merely because a subject appears in more than one statutory list. Verify the applicable allocation and the exact order. S1, sections 356, 357 and 362
Preserve limitation and admission conditions
The first-appeal period in section 358 is generally thirty days from the specified service event, with sufficient-cause condonation available. The fee and admitted-income tax conditions are separate. Form 99 is prescribed by Rule 167. Filing grounds does not by itself suspend collection or prove that the appeal has been admitted. S1, section 358; S2, rule 167
Choose the governing Act before choosing the appeal route
This article explains the 2025 Act. Section 536 preserves the earlier Act for the specified earlier-year proceedings; the date of an appellate order alone does not decide which Act governs. Keep the assessment period, initiating proceeding, order appealed against and its communication record together. The section numbers and new prescribed forms here should not be copied automatically into a saved 1961-Act proceeding. S1, section 536(2)(c)
Hypothetical illustrations
A DRP-directed assessment needs the exception check
Facts: For tax year 2026–27, an AO makes a section 270(10) order in pursuance of DRP directions.
Assumptions: The stated facts are hypothetical and supported by records. Any rates illustrated are base income-tax rates; surcharge, cess, interest and penalties are excluded unless expressly calculated.
Question: Should it be treated as an ordinary clause (d) first appeal?
Analysis: No. The DRP exclusion must be respected and the section 362(1)(d) direct ITAT route examined. The general assessment label does not override the specific route.
Conclusion: Match the directions and final order before selecting the forum. S1
Reader questions
Does the list decide whether the taxpayer’s arguments succeed?
No. It identifies appealable order categories. Filing requirements, maintainability and the merits remain separate questions. S1