At a glance
| Item | Position |
|---|---|
| Act and provision | Income-tax Act, 2025, section 35 |
| Official heading | Amounts not deductible in certain circumstances. |
| Location | Chapter IV, Part D: Profits and gains of business or profession |
| Legal status | Enacted and operative; editorial draft |
| General commencement | 1 April 2026 |
| Legal function | Overriding business deduction restrictions |
Income taxes and the overriding rule
The opening words override other provisions of Chapter IV-D. Clause (a) denies a deduction for tax paid on income, employer tax referred to in Schedule III Table row 10, and foreign tax eligible for relief under section 159 or 160. It includes surcharge and cess on those taxes. This is not a general denial of every business levy: identify which tax the clause describes. S1, section 35, opening words and (a)(i)–(iii)
Resident payments with withholding failure
Clause (b)(i) disallows 30% of a sum payable to a resident where tax is deductible under Chapter XIX-B but is not deducted during the tax year, or after deduction is not paid by the section 263(1) due date. It is a deduction disallowance, not a 30% TDS rate. If deduction occurs in a subsequent year, or current-year deduction is paid after the return due date, the disallowed 30% is allowed in the year the tax is paid. S1, section 35(b)(i), (A)
Where failure to deduct does not result in default because section 398(2) is satisfied, the tax is deemed deducted and paid on the payee’s return-filing date. The payee must have filed the required return, included the amount and paid the tax due, and the payer must furnish the prescribed accountant certificate. Rule 221 specifies Form 149 for non-deduction or short deduction, furnished to the Director General of Income-tax (Systems) or authorised person. A verbal assurance that the payee paid tax is not the complete statutory route. S1, sections 35(b)(i)(B) and 398(2); S2, rule 221
Overseas/non-resident sums, employee funds and salary
Clause (b)(ii) concerns interest, royalty, technical-service fees or another chargeable sum payable outside India, or in India to a non-resident other than a company or to a foreign company, where required tax is not deducted during the year or not paid by the section 263(1) deadline. Unlike clause (b)(i), the clause disallows the relevant sum, not merely 30%. It provides later deduction in the tax-payment year and the same section 398(2) deemed-payment route using the payee’s return date. Chargeability and the actual withholding obligation must first be established. S1, section 35(b)(ii)(A)–(B), (I)–(II)
Clause (b)(iii) denies a payment to an employee-benefit provident or other fund unless effective arrangements secure withholding from the fund’s salary-chargeable payments. Clause (c) separately covers salary payable outside India or to a non-resident where required tax has not been deducted or paid. Do not automatically copy the return-due-date wording from clause (b) into the differently worded salary clause. S1, section 35(b)(iii), (c)
State Government undertakings
Clause (d) disallows the described royalty, licence, service, privilege or other fee or charge levied exclusively on a State Government undertaking by the State Government, and amounts appropriated directly or indirectly from it by that Government. The inclusive definition in section 66(34) covers statutory corporations, the specified majority-owned companies and controlled bodies, including the stated indirect control structures. This is not a rule disallowing every ordinary payment a private business makes to a State Government. S1, sections 35(d)(i)–(ii) and 66(34)
Firm payments: deed and working-partner conditions
Clause (e)(i) denies salary, bonus, commission or other remuneration to a partner who is not a working partner. A working partner is an individual actively conducting the firm’s business or professional affairs. Clause (e)(ii) also restricts remuneration to a working partner and interest to any partner where the applicable deed does not authorise it, or where the described earlier-period/deed-authorisation defect exists. A later deed should not simply be assumed to validate earlier unauthorised payments. S1, section 35(e)(i)–(ii), (v)(B)
Under clause (e)(iii), the aggregate working-partner remuneration ceiling is the higher of ₹3,00,000 or 90% of the first ₹6,00,000 of book profit, including the stated loss case, plus 60% of the remaining book profit. This is a combined ceiling for all working partners, not per partner. Book profit means Chapter IV-D-computed net profit in the profit-and-loss account, adding back remuneration to all partners if deducted in arriving at that profit. The ceiling does not itself authorise a payment absent the deed conditions. S1, section 35(e)(iii), (v)(A)
Partner interest and representative capacities
Clause (e)(iv) disallows authorised partner interest exceeding 12% simple interest per annum. Where an individual is a representative partner, interest paid personally outside that capacity is excluded from this clause’s reckoning, while interest paid in the representative capacity and to the represented person is included. Where the individual is a partner in a non-representative capacity, interest received on behalf of or for another person is excluded from this reckoning. These are capacity rules; establish whose funds and beneficial receipt are involved instead of applying the partner limit merely from the bank-account name. S1, section 35(e)(iv)(A)–(B)
AOP and BOI payments to members
Clause (f) disallows the described interest, salary, bonus, commission or remuneration to a member of an association of persons or body of individuals. Its scope excludes companies, co-operative societies, and societies registered under the Societies Registration Act, 1860 or corresponding Indian law. Where interest is paid both ways between the association/body and member, only the excess interest paid by the association/body is disallowed under this clause. S1, section 35(f), (i)
For a representative member, clause (f)(ii) excludes personal-capacity interest paid to or received from that person, and includes interest in the representative capacity and to or from the represented person. It also excludes interest paid to a non-representative member on behalf of or for another person. These capacity rules do not create a general permission to deduct member salaries. S1, section 35(f)(ii)(A)–(C)
Hypothetical illustrations
Resident expense with TDS failure
Facts: In tax year 2026–27 a ₹2,00,000 resident service payment is otherwise deductible, but required tax is not deducted during the year or paid by the relevant deadline.
Assumptions: No section 398(2) relief is available and no other disallowance is being calculated.
Question: What does clause (b)(i) disallow?
Analysis: 30% × ₹2,00,000 = ₹60,000. This is the expense disallowance, not the withholding tax itself.
Conclusion: ₹60,000 is disallowed under this clause; later tax payment may permit the statutory later-year deduction. S1
Aggregate working-partner ceiling
Facts: For tax year 2026–27 the firm’s correctly calculated book profit is ₹10,00,000 and authorised working-partner remuneration totals ₹8,00,000.
Assumptions: The recipients and deed satisfy the conditions; no other restriction applies.
Question: What is the maximum under clause (e)(iii)?
Analysis: First ₹6,00,000: 90% = ₹5,40,000, higher than ₹3,00,000. Remaining ₹4,00,000: 60% = ₹2,40,000. Total ceiling = ₹7,80,000.
Conclusion: The excess ₹20,000 is disallowed; ₹7,80,000 fits this ceiling. S1
Reciprocal AOP interest
Facts: An AOP pays a covered member ₹70,000 interest and the same member pays the AOP ₹20,000 interest in tax year 2026–27.
Assumptions: Clause (f) applies and no representative-capacity exclusion changes the facts.
Question: How much is disallowed under the reciprocal-interest rule?
Analysis: ₹70,000 − ₹20,000 = ₹50,000.
Conclusion: Clause (f)(i) disallows ₹50,000 on these facts. S1
Reader questions
Does later TDS payment erase all withholding consequences?
The later-deduction provision concerns the expense computation. Separate default and interest rules, including section 398, must still be considered. S1
Can each working partner claim the whole remuneration ceiling for the firm?
No. Clause (e)(iii) limits aggregate remuneration to all working partners; deed and working-partner eligibility remain separate conditions. S1