At a glance
| Item | Position |
|---|---|
| Act and provision | Income-tax Act, 2025, section 274 |
| Official heading | Reference to Principal Commissioner or Commissioner in certain cases. |
| Location | Chapter XVI: Procedure for assessment; Part A: Procedure for assessment |
| General commencement | 1 April 2026 |
| Research date | 15 October 2026 |
| Legal status | Enacted and operative |
| Legal function | GAAR reference and approval procedure |
The section operates within the Act’s charging and computation framework. The period and applicable version must be identified before applying it. S1, sections 1(3), 3, 4 and 274
Start with a reasoned reference
During assessment or reassessment, the AO may refer a matter to the Principal Commissioner or Commissioner if the available material and evidence make it necessary to declare an impermissible avoidance arrangement and determine Chapter XI consequences. Tax benefit alone is not the complete substantive GAAR test; Chapter XI supplies that test and applicable exclusions. S1, Section 274(1)(a), Section 274(1)(b)
The Commissioner’s three possible routes
If GAAR appears necessary, the Commissioner issues reasons and basis, invites objections and provides a hearing within the notice period, which cannot exceed sixty days. No timely objection permits appropriate directions declaring the arrangement impermissible. If the assessee objects but the explanation does not satisfy the Commissioner after hearing, the matter goes to the Approving Panel. If satisfied that GAAR is unnecessary, the Commissioner communicates a written order to the AO with a copy to the assessee. S1, Section 274(2)(a), Section 274(2)(b), Section 274(3), Section 274(4), Section 274(5)
The Panel’s decision and evidence powers
The Panel issues directions on the declaration and identifies the tax year or years covered. Before prejudicial directions, it must hear the assessee or AO as appropriate to the affected interest. It can obtain further inquiry and a report through the Commissioner, inspect records and require documents/evidence from the assessee. Differences are resolved by majority. S1, Section 274(6)(a), Section 274(6)(b), Section 274(7), Section 274(8)(a), Section 274(8)(b), Section 274(8)(c), Section 274(9)
Giving effect is subject to approval
The AO completes the proceedings according to the Commissioner’s no-objection directions or the Panel’s directions and Chapter XI. If Panel directions cover another year, that year’s assessment/reassessment follows them without a fresh direction on the same issue. An assessment/reassessment determining GAAR tax consequences requires prior Principal Commissioner/Commissioner approval. S1, Section 274(10), Section 274(11)(a), Section 274(11)(b), Section 274(12)
The Panel’s clock is not simply six months in every case
The ordinary limit is six months from the end of the month when the Panel receives the Commissioner’s reference. Exclude the period for the Panel’s first direction to obtain section 159 treaty information until the last requested information arrives, capped at one year; also exclude a court stay until the Panel receives the certified order vacating it. If fewer than sixty days remain after the exclusion, extend the remaining period to sixty days. S1, Section 274(13), Section 274(14)(a), Section 274(14)(b), Section 274(15)
Binding directions and the appeal boundary
Panel directions bind the assessee, Commissioner and subordinate tax authorities. No appeal under this Act lies against those directions themselves. This statement does not mean that every subsequent assessment order or constitutional remedy is abolished: section 362(1)(e) separately addresses an assessment made with section 274(12) approval. Distinguish the Panel’s direction from the eventual assessment order. S1, Section 274(16)(a), Section 274(16)(b), Section 274(17)
Constitution and administration of the Panel
Central Government may constitute one or more three-member Panels. The chair is a serving or former High Court judge; the other members are an IRS officer of at least Principal Chief Commissioner/Chief Commissioner rank and an academic or scholar with the specified specialist knowledge. The term is ordinarily one year, extendable from time to time up to three years. Members meet when required and receive prescribed remuneration. Section 387 powers apply with necessary adaptations; CBDT provides staff and may make rules for constitution, functioning and prompt disposal. S1, Section 274(18), Section 274(19)(a), Section 274(19)(b), Section 274(20), Section 274(21), Section 274(22), Section 274(23), Section 274(24)
Forms and earlier procedural safeguards
Rule 129 requires an AO notice before reference, identifying the arrangement, tax benefit, main-purpose basis, section 179(1)(a)–(d) grounds and relied-on documents. Form 62 is the AO reference; Form 63 records that GAAR need not be invoked; Form 64 records satisfaction and refers to the Panel in four Hindi/English sets. For an IFSC entity, the Commissioner seeks a specific written factual report from IFSCA before the Panel reference. Rule 131 requires circulation to members within seven days and notice to the AO and assessee. Rule 132 provides a ₹6,000 daily sitting fee and prescribed travel/daily allowances, paid from Revenue Department grants. S2, rules 129, 131–132
The Commissioner also has prescribed deadlines
Rule 130 limits no-objection directions to one month from the end of the compliance month and the Panel reference to two months from the end of the month of the final response. A Form 63 conclusion is due within one month from the reference-receipt month-end when reached on the AO reference, or two months from the final-submission month-end when reached after the assessee’s response. These clocks differ from the Panel’s six-month clock. S2, rule 130
Hypothetical illustrations
A timely objection changes the decision route
Facts: For tax year 2026–27, the taxpayer objects to the Commissioner’s proposed GAAR treatment within the notice period, but the Commissioner remains unsatisfied after hearing.
Assumptions: The stated facts are hypothetical and supported by records. Any rates illustrated are base income-tax rates; surcharge, cess, interest and penalties are excluded unless expressly calculated.
Question: Can the Commissioner use the no-objection route instead?
Analysis: No. Subsection (4) directs a reference to the Approving Panel in that situation; subsection (3) addresses failure to furnish objections in time.
Conclusion: The response determines which statutory route applies. S1
Reader questions
Does the Panel have to seek fresh directions for every covered year?
No. Where its direction specifies another tax year, subsection (11) allows that year’s assessment/reassessment to follow the same directions without a fresh direction on the issue. S1