At a glance
| Item | Position |
|---|---|
| Act and provision | Income-tax Act, 2025, section 174 |
| Official heading | Avoidance of income-tax by transactions resulting in transfer of income to non-residents. |
| Location | Chapter X: Special provisions relating to avoidance of tax |
| Legal status | Enacted and operative; editorial draft |
| Research date | 13 October 2026 |
| General commencement | 1 April 2026 |
| Legal function | Income transferred to non-residents |
The section operates within the Act’s charging and computation framework. The period and applicable version must be identified before applying it. S1, sections 1(3), 3, 4 and 174
Subsection (1): the transfer and resulting income
The section addresses asset transfers before and after commencement where, by virtue or consequence of the transfer alone or with associated operations, income becomes payable to a non-resident. The fact that the arrangement began before 1 April 2026 does not by itself take later relevant income outside the wording; earlier tax periods still require section 536’s savings. The inquiry concerns the causal link, not merely the existence of a foreign account. S1, Section 174(1)(a), Section 174(1)(b)
Subsection (2): retained power to enjoy
Where the first-mentioned person acquires rights through the transfer/operations giving power to enjoy the non-resident’s income immediately or in future, and that income would be chargeable if it were the person’s own, the income is deemed that person’s income for all purposes. Actual immediate payment into that person’s bank account is not required. The section’s broad enjoyment tests determine whether the necessary power exists. S1, Section 174(2)(a), Section 174(2)(b)
Subsection (3): connected capital sums
A second route applies where the first-mentioned person receives or is entitled to a capital sum connected in any way with the transfer or associated operations, before or after the transfer. Income becoming the non-resident’s by the transfer/operations is then attributed as specified. Calling a connected receipt “capital” or “loan” is not conclusive because the section expressly addresses these forms. S1, Section 174(3)(a), Section 174(3)(b)
Subsection (4): subsequent receipt is not taxed twice under the deeming
If the person has already been charged to income-tax on income deemed theirs under this section and later receives that income, as income or in another form, it is not again deemed part of their income. Keep a traceable reconciliation between the earlier attributed income and the later receipt. This prevents repeated attribution of the same income; it is not an exemption for every future remittance. S1, Section 174(4)
Subsection (5): two statutory defences
The person may satisfy the Assessing Officer that neither the transfer nor any associated operation had avoidance of tax liability as a purpose or one of its purposes; alternatively, that the transfer and all associated operations were bona fide commercial transactions not designed to avoid taxation. The alternatives require evidence of the whole relevant chain, not merely one commercially useful step. S1, Section 174(5)(a), Section 174(5)(b)
Subsection (6)(a)–(b): look through substituted assets and foreign bodies
References to assets representing transferred assets, income or accumulations include shares in, or obligations of, companies and obligations of other persons to whom those items have been transferred. For this section, a body corporate incorporated outside India is treated as non-resident. That special rule should not be turned into a universal statement about residence under section 6. S1, Section 174(6)(a), Section 174(6)(b)
Subsection (6)(c): five ways enjoyment can exist
Power to enjoy includes: income handled so that it will eventually benefit the person in any form; receipt/accrual increasing the value of assets held by or for the person; entitlement to a benefit funded by that income or its successive effects; an appointment, revocation or other power to obtain beneficial enjoyment, with or without another person’s consent; and direct or indirect control over how the income is applied. Each is an alternative factual route, so retained economic control can matter despite formal foreign ownership. S1, Section 174(6)(c)(i), Section 174(6)(c)(ii), Section 174(6)(c)(iii), Section 174(6)(c)(iv), Section 174(6)(c)(v)
Subsection (6)(d): substance and all benefits
In deciding enjoyment, examine the substantial result and effect of the transfer and associated operations and all benefits that may accrue at any time, whatever their nature or form. A narrow review of the transfer deed alone may miss what later connected steps accomplish. S1, Section 174(6)(d)
Subsection (7): broad asset, operation and payment terms
Assets include property or rights of any kind, and transfer of rights includes creating them. Associated operation covers operations by any person involving transferred assets, direct/indirect representative assets, income from them or assets representing accumulated income. Benefit includes any payment. Capital sum includes loan payments/repayments and other non-income sums not paid for full money or money’s-worth consideration. Ordinary full-value consideration should not be automatically treated as the residual capital-sum category. S1, Section 174(7)(a), Section 174(7)(b)(i), Section 174(7)(b)(ii), Section 174(7)(b)(iii), Section 174(7)(b)(iv), Section 174(7)(c), Section 174(7)(d)(i), Section 174(7)(d)(ii)
A practical evidence trail
Map what was transferred, who receives the income, who can direct its use, what benefits or connected payments return, and the commercial reasons for every associated operation. Distinguish this attribution rule from ordinary source/residence taxation and Chapter XI GAAR. The ₹3 crore GAAR rule should not be imported as a threshold into section 174. S1, sections 174, 178–184
Hypothetical illustrations
Control without immediate remittance
Facts: For tax year 2026–27, a person transfers income-producing rights to a foreign body corporate but retains an enforceable power to direct the resulting income for their own benefit.
Assumptions: Facts are hypothetical and documented as stated. No additional exemption or special agreement changes the stated treatment.
Question: Can attribution arise before cash is remitted?
Analysis: Yes, if the subsection (2) conditions and subsection (6) enjoyment tests are met and the subsection (5) exception is not established.
Conclusion: The conclusion turns on the retained rights and facts, not foreign ownership alone. S1
Later receipt of already charged income
Facts: For tax year 2026–27, ₹8 lakh of income was already charged to the person under section 174 and the same identified income is later received.
Assumptions: Facts are hypothetical and documented as stated. No additional exemption or special agreement changes the stated treatment.
Question: Is that receipt deemed income again under this section?
Analysis: Subsection (4) prevents the same attributed income being deemed income again on the later receipt.
Conclusion: Evidence must connect the receipt to the amount already charged. S1
Reader questions
Does every genuine transfer to a foreign company fail?
No. The attribution gateways and statutory exceptions must be applied to the actual transfer and associated operations. S1