At a glance
| Item | Position |
|---|---|
| Act and provision | Income-tax Act, 2025, section 165 |
| Official heading | Determination of arm’s length price. |
| Location | Chapter X: Special provisions relating to avoidance of tax |
| Legal status | Enacted and operative; editorial draft |
| Research date | 13 October 2026 |
| General commencement | 1 April 2026 |
| Legal function | Transfer-pricing methods and assessment |
The section operates within the Act’s charging and computation framework. The period and applicable version must be identified before applying it. S1, sections 1(3), 3, 4 and 165
Subsection (1)(a): Comparable uncontrolled price
Compare the price for comparable property or services between uncontrolled parties, making reliable adjustments for material differences. The operational detail is prescribed by Rules 78–79. S2, rules 78–79 S1, Section 165(1)(a)
Subsection (1)(b): Resale price
Start with the unrelated resale price, deduct a comparable normal gross margin and relevant purchase-related expenses, and adjust material functional/accounting differences. The operational detail is prescribed by Rules 78–79. S2, rules 78–79 S1, Section 165(1)(b)
Subsection (1)(c): Cost plus
Identify direct and indirect production or service costs, then apply a comparable, appropriately adjusted gross profit markup using consistent accounting. The operational detail is prescribed by Rules 78–79. S2, rules 78–79 S1, Section 165(1)(c)
Subsection (1)(d): Profit split
Identify combined relevant profit and allocate it according to contributions, functions, assets and risks. Rule 79 recognises contribution and residual approaches, especially for unique intangibles, valuable contributions or closely interrelated transactions. The operational detail is prescribed by Rules 78–79. S2, rules 78–79 S1, Section 165(1)(d)
Subsection (1)(e): Transactional net margin
Compare transaction-related net profit on a suitable and consistent base such as costs, sales or assets, after material comparability adjustments. The operational detail is prescribed by Rules 78–79. S2, rules 78–79 S1, Section 165(1)(e)
Subsection (1)(f): Other prescribed method
Rule 78 permits a method considering a price charged, paid or that would have been charged or paid for the same or similar uncontrolled transaction under similar circumstances. It is evidence-based, not unrestricted discretion. The operational detail is prescribed by Rules 78–79. S2, rules 78–79 S1, Section 165(1)(f)
Subsection (2): choose the most reliable method
Select the most appropriate method with regard to the transaction/class, associated enterprises, functions and other prescribed factors, then apply the prescribed manner. Rule 80 also requires attention to data availability/reliability, comparability, reliable adjustments and the nature and reliability of assumptions. There is no automatic statutory preference for the method producing the smallest adjustment. S2, rule 80 S1, Section 165(2)(a), Section 165(2)(b)
Subsection (3): one price and multiple prices
Where the chosen method produces one price, that price applies, subject to the notified variation rule. The actual transaction price may be retained if the variation does not exceed the notified percentage, whose statutory ceiling is 3% of the actual transaction price. The ceiling is not a universal automatic 3% deduction. Where the method produces multiple prices, use the prescribed mechanism rather than selecting the most favourable comparable. S1, Section 165(3)(a)(i), Section 165(3)(a)(ii), Section 165(3)(b)
Rules 79–81: comparability, data and the range
Comparability turns on property/service characteristics, functions-assets-risks, contractual terms and market conditions. Differences must either have no material effect or permit reasonably accurate adjustments. Current-year data is the baseline. For resale price, cost plus and TNMM, first-preceding-year data can be used when current-year data is unavailable at filing; subsequently available current-year data is used in assessment. Rule 81 contains the qualifying multi-year weighted-data rules; an unweighted average of three annual margins is not automatically correct. S2, rules 79(2)–(5), 80–81
For CUP, resale price, cost plus or TNMM with six or more properly constructed dataset entries, Rule 81 uses the 35th–65th percentile range. An actual price within it is accepted; outside it, the median is used. Otherwise the arithmetic mean applies, with the applicable notified variation rule where available. Rule 81 specifies percentile/median interpolation; ordinary spreadsheet defaults need not reproduce it. Use the operative notification for the relevant tax year before applying a particular tolerance; the statutory ceiling alone does not establish that percentage. S2, rule 81(2)–(8)
Subsection (4): when the Assessing Officer may intervene
The officer may determine the price on relevant material where the taxpayer did not follow subsections (1)–(3), failed to maintain section 171(1) documents, used unreliable/incorrect data, or failed to supply documents within the section 171 notice period. These are separate statutory grounds; a disagreement should be tied to evidence and a stated defect. S1, Section 165(4)(a), Section 165(4)(b), Section 165(4)(c), Section 165(4)(d)
Subsections (5)–(6): notice and resulting computation
Before making that determination, the officer must issue a show-cause notice identifying the specified hearing date/time and asking why the available material should not be used. After determination, total income may be computed having regard to the arm’s length price. A proposed benchmark is therefore not already a completed assessment. S1, Section 165(5), Section 165(6)
Subsections (7)–(8): two important limits
Chapter VIII deductions are unavailable on the amount by which total income is enhanced under subsection (6). In the specified payment case where tax was deducted or deductible under Chapter XIX-B, the other associated enterprise’s income is not recomputed merely because the payer’s arm’s length price is determined under subsection (6). Do not assume an automatic matching domestic reduction for the counterparty. S1, Section 165(7), Section 165(8)
Finance Act, 2026 version
The words “under section 144 or” were omitted from subsection (7) from 1 April 2026; its current prohibition refers to Chapter VIII. S1; S4, section 52
Hypothetical illustrations
A supported cost-plus result
Facts: For tax year 2026–27, eligible costs are ₹80 lakh and a reliable comparability analysis establishes an adjusted gross markup of 20%.
Assumptions: Facts are hypothetical and documented as stated. No additional exemption or special agreement changes the stated treatment.
Question: What price follows from the stipulated inputs?
Analysis: ₹80 lakh + (₹80 lakh × 20%) = ₹96 lakh.
Conclusion: The 20% is an assumed benchmark from evidence, not a rate prescribed by section 165. S1, S2
Range rather than the best comparable
Facts: For tax year 2026–27, a correctly constructed CUP dataset contains seven prices: ₹90, ₹95, ₹100, ₹105, ₹110, ₹115 and ₹120 per unit.
Assumptions: Facts are hypothetical and documented as stated. No additional exemption or special agreement changes the stated treatment.
Question: What are the range and outside-range result?
Analysis: The 35th position is 2.45, giving the third value ₹100; the 65th is 4.55, giving the fifth ₹110. The median is the fourth value ₹105. An actual price of ₹98 is outside and is tested against ₹105, not merely ₹100.
Conclusion: All seven observations are assumed genuinely comparable; section 161(4) still governs direction. S1, S2
Reader questions
Can I subtract 3% from every adjustment?
No. Section 165 refers to a notified variation within a statutory ceiling and compares it with the actual transaction price. Range cases have their own mechanism. S1