Key Takeaways
- Source-Based Taxation: Under the India-US DTAA, income from immovable property, including capital gains, is primarily taxed in the country where the property is located. For property in India, the capital gains will be taxed in India.
- Stricter Residency Rules Proposed: The proposed Direct Tax Code may introduce stricter residency rules. For instance, high-income NRIs spending 120 days or more in India could be classified as 'Resident but Not Ordinarily Resident' (RNOR), potentially impacting their global income taxation.
- Compliance is Non-Negotiable: To claim DTAA benefits, providing a Tax Residency Certificate (TRC) from the country of residence is mandatory. If the TRC lacks prescribed details, the electronic filing of Form 10F is required to supplement the information.
- Repatriation Formalities: Repatriating sale proceeds is subject to limits under the Foreign Exchange Management Act (FEMA), typically USD 1 million per financial year, and requires adherence to strict documentation, including Forms 15CA and 15CB.
PART 1: EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
(Target: 200 Words. Clear overview of the tax change.)
This guide outlines the compliance framework for Non-Resident Indians (NRIs), particularly those residing in the US, when claiming relief under the Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement (DTAA) for real estate transactions in India, in light of the proposed transition to the Direct Tax Code (DTC) 2025 for the tax year 2026.
-
The Old Law (Income Tax Act, 1961): The 1961 Act, amended over decades, governs NRI taxation. Capital gains on property held for over 24 months are taxed at a flat 20% (plus surcharge and cess) with the benefit of indexation. To claim DTAA relief, NRIs must furnish a TRC and Form 10F. TDS is deducted by the buyer under Section 195 on the sale consideration, which often leads to claiming refunds later.
-
The New Law (Proposed Direct Tax Code 2025): The DTC aims to simplify and modernize India's tax laws. Key proposals suggest eliminating indexation benefits for capital gains, potentially introducing a new tax rate (e.g., 12.5% without indexation). The DTC is also expected to tighten residency rules, potentially classifying more NRIs as residents for tax purposes based on their stay in India. The core principles of the DTAA will remain, but procedural compliance is expected to become more stringent and digitized.
-
Who is Impacted: This transition primarily affects US-based NRIs who own and transact in Indian real estate. The changes will impact how their capital gains are calculated, the tax rates applied, their residency status, and the compliance procedures for claiming DTAA benefits and repatriating funds.
PART 2: DETAILED TAX ANALYSIS
1. Background for Non-Resident Indians
For a Non-Resident Indian (NRI) residing in the United States, any income generated from the sale of real estate in India is subject to tax in India. This is known as source-based taxation and is a fundamental principle in international tax treaties. Under Article 6 of the India-US DTAA, income derived from immovable property is taxable in the country where the property is situated. Therefore, India retains the primary right to tax capital gains arising from the sale of property located in India.
The key challenge for NRIs is "double taxation," where the same income could potentially be taxed both in India (the source country) and the US (the country of residence). The DTAA between India and the US provides a mechanism to prevent this by allowing the NRI to claim a Foreign Tax Credit (FTC) in their US tax return for the taxes paid in India.
To avail the benefits of the DTAA, such as a potentially lower withholding tax (TDS) rate, an NRI must prove their tax residency in the US by providing a valid Tax Residency Certificate (TRC) to the Indian tax authorities.
2. Comparison: 1961 Act vs Direct Tax Code 2025
The proposed shift to the Direct Tax Code (DTC) aims to simplify the tax structure. Here is a comparative analysis for NRIs engaged in real estate transactions:
| Feature | Income Tax Act, 1961 (The Old Law) | Proposed Direct Tax Code 2025 (The New Law) |
|---|---|---|
| Capital Gains Calculation | Long-Term Capital Gains (LTCG) on property held for >24 months are calculated as Sale Price minus Indexed Cost of Acquisition. Indexation accounts for inflation, reducing the taxable gain. | Proposals have suggested the removal of the indexation benefit for calculating capital gains. This would mean the gain is a simpler calculation of Sale Price minus the original Purchase Cost. |
| LTCG Tax Rate | Taxed at a flat rate of 20% plus applicable surcharge and cess. | To compensate for the removal of indexation, a lower tax rate, such as 12.5%, has been proposed in various drafts. |
| Residency Rules | An individual is an NRI if they are in India for less than 182 days in a financial year, or less than 60 days if they have also been in India for 365 days in the preceding 4 years. For visiting NRIs with Indian income over ₹15 lakh, this 60-day period is extended to 120 days. | The DTC proposes stricter residency criteria. One key proposal suggests that NRIs with Indian income over ₹15 lakh who stay in India for 120 days or more in a year (and 365+ days in the prior 4 years) will be treated as Resident but Not Ordinarily Resident (RNOR). This would bring their Indian-sourced income firmly into the tax net. |
| TDS under Sec 195 | The buyer is required to deduct TDS at 20% (plus surcharge) on the entire sale value for LTCG. The NRI can apply for a lower deduction certificate (Form 13) if the actual tax liability is lower, but this is a procedural step. | The mechanism of TDS is expected to continue. However, with simplified gain calculation, the process for obtaining a lower/nil deduction certificate might be streamlined. The focus will remain on ensuring tax is collected at the source. |
| DTAA Benefit Claim | Requires a Tax Residency Certificate (TRC) from the US and furnishing a self-declaration in Form 10F if the TRC does not contain all the required information. | The requirement for a TRC and Form 10F will continue and is likely to be strictly enforced through digital means. The DTC's emphasis on transparency will make accurate and timely submission critical. |
3. Repatriation & DTAA Implications
Repatriating funds from an Indian NRO account to a US bank account is a two-step process involving tax compliance and FEMA regulations.
Tax Compliance: Before repatriation, the NRI must demonstrate that all applicable taxes on the income have been paid. This is done through a Chartered Accountant who verifies the tax payments and issues Form 15CB. Based on this certificate, the NRI files Form 15CA, a declaration submitted to the Income Tax Department. These forms are mandatory for the bank to process the foreign remittance.
FEMA Regulations: Under the Liberalised Remittance Scheme (LRS), an NRI can repatriate up to USD 1 million per financial year from their NRO account. This limit includes proceeds from the sale of property. For amounts exceeding this, special approval from the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) is required.
- Impact of DTAA on Repatriation: While the DTAA itself does not govern the mechanical process of repatriation, it is central to determining the final tax liability. By claiming DTAA benefits, the NRI ensures the correct amount of tax is paid in India, which is a prerequisite for the issuance of Form 15CB and the subsequent fund transfer. Incorrectly applying the DTAA can lead to scrutiny from tax authorities and delays in repatriation.
4. NRI Action Plan & Documentation
For the tax year 2026, US-based NRIs selling property in India must prepare meticulously.
Step 1: Pre-Sale Preparation
- Obtain a Tax Residency Certificate (TRC): Apply for your TRC from the US Internal Revenue Service (IRS) well in advance. This is the foundational document for claiming DTAA benefits.
- Update PAN Card: Ensure your Indian Permanent Account Number (PAN) is active and linked with your Aadhaar (if applicable).
- Engage a Chartered Accountant: Appoint a CA in India to compute the anticipated capital gains tax under both the 1961 Act and the proposed DTC rules to understand the potential tax outflow.
Step 2: During the Sale Transaction
- Calculate TDS Liability: Work with the buyer to ensure the correct TDS amount is calculated. If your actual tax liability is lower than the standard TDS rate on the sale price, instruct your CA to file Form 13 to obtain a lower tax deduction certificate from the Income Tax Department.
- Verify TDS Deposit: Ensure the buyer deposits the deducted TDS with the government and provides you with Form 16A as proof.
Step 3: Post-Sale Compliance & Repatriation
- File Indian Income Tax Return (ITR): File your ITR in India to report the capital gains and claim a refund if excess TDS was deducted.
- Documentation for Repatriation: To repatriate funds, provide the following to your Indian bank:
- Form 15CA (Self-Declaration) and Form 15CB (CA Certificate).
- Copy of the Sale Deed.
- Proof of TDS paid (Form 16A).
- A completed application form for foreign remittance as required by the bank.
Step 4: US Tax Compliance
- Report Global Income: Report the capital gain on your US tax return.
- Claim Foreign Tax Credit (FTC): Use IRS Form 1116 (Foreign Tax Credit) to claim a credit for the taxes you have paid in India. This prevents double taxation and is the ultimate benefit of the India-US DTAA.
5. Conclusion
The proposed transition to the Direct Tax Code 2025 signals a move towards a simpler, more transparent tax regime in India. For US-based NRIs with real estate investments, this change necessitates a proactive approach to tax planning and compliance. While the fundamental principles of the India-US DTAA will continue to provide relief from double taxation, the methods of calculating gains, applicable tax rates, and residency criteria are poised for a significant overhaul. Adherence to documentation requirements, such as the TRC and Forms 15CA/CB, will be more critical than ever to ensure a smooth transaction, successful repatriation of funds, and full compliance in both jurisdictions. Our team advises NRIs to monitor legislative developments closely and engage with tax professionals to navigate this evolving landscape effectively.
💡 NRI Tax Tip: Managing foreign assets or DTAA? Ensure you are compliant with the updated NRI taxation rules in 2025.